Many loci make light work: High individual diversity despite low population diversity and random mating at class I MHC in a Critically Endangered island songbird

Abstract

Multi-cellular organisms are under constant attack from parasites, making immune defence a critical aspect of fitness. In vertebrate animals, genes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) determine the breadth of pathogens to which individuals can respond. Having many MHC alleles can confer better protection against infectious disease, and balancing selection at MHC is widespread. Indeed, MHC loci are famously variable, with some populations harbouring thousands of alleles (Biedrzycka et al., 2018; Robinson, Soormally, Hayhurst, & Marsh, 2016). MHC has also long fascinated behavioural ecologists because mate choice-for example, preferring MHC-dissimilar partners-may amplify the effects of natural selection (Penn & Potts, 1999). But despite keen interest in the evolutionary ecology of MHC, extensive duplication (Minias, Pikus, Whittingham, & Dunn, 2019) has made these genes challenging to study. In a From the Cover article in this issue of Molecular Ecology, Stervander, Dierickx, Thorley, Brooke, and Westerdahl (2020) characterizes class I MHC in a Critically Endangered songbird, relating genotype to mate choice and survivorship. By inferring copy number and patterns of allelic co-segregation, the authors pave the way to elucidating the genomic architecture of MHC in this bottlenecked population. These insights help reconcile apparently counterintuitive findings: no effect of MHC genotype on mate choice or survival, and high MHC diversity within individuals despite low diversity at the population level. The latter finding is cause for optimism regarding conservation prospects. Moreover, these results suggest that ancient duplication events can have longstanding effects on the adaptive landscapes of natural and sexual selection.

Keywords: Alauda razae; conservation genetics; gene duplication; major histocompatibility complex; mate choice.