Sparing effect of peritoneal dialysis vs hemodialysis on BMD changes and its impact on mortality

Abstract

Introduction: Bone loss in end stage renal disease (ESRD) patients associates with fractures, vascular calcification, cardiovascular disease (CVD) and increased mortality. We investigated factors associated with changes of bone mineral density (ΔBMD) during the initial year on dialysis therapy and associations of ΔBMD with subsequent mortality in ESRD patients initiating dialysis.

Materials and methods: In 242 ESRD patients (median age 55 years, 61% men) starting dialysis with peritoneal dialysis (PD; n = 138) or hemodialysis (HD; n = 104), whole-body dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA), body composition, nutritional status and circulating biomarkers were assessed at baseline and 1 year after dialysis start. We used multivariate linear regression analysis to determine factors associated with ΔBMD, and fine and gray competing risk analysis to determine associations of ΔBMD with subsequent mortality risk.

Results: BMD decreased significantly in HD patients (significant reductions of BMD_total and BMD_{leg, trunk, rib, pelvis and spine}) but not in PD patients. HD compared to PD therapy associated with negative changes in BMD_{total (β=- 0.15)}, BMD_{head (β=- 0.14)}, BMD_{leg (β=- 0.18)} and BMD_{trunk (β=- 0.16)}. Better preservation of BMD associated with significantly lower all-cause mortality for ΔBMD_total (sub-hazard ratio, sHR, 0.91), ΔBMD_head (sHR 0.91) and ΔBMD_leg (sHR 0.92), while only ΔBMD_head (sHR 0.92) had a beneficial effect on CVD-mortality.

Conclusions: PD had beneficial effect compared with HD on BMD changes during first year of dialysis therapy. Better preservation of BMD, especially in bone sites rich in cortical bone, associated with lower subsequent mortality. BMD in cortical bone may have stronger association with clinical outcome than BMD in trabecular bone.

Keywords: Bone mineral density; Dialysis; End-stage renal disease; Mortality; Renal osteodystrophy.