Provocative dose and dose-response curve to inhaled propranolol in asthmatic patients with bronchial hyperresponsiveness to methacholine

Abstract

This study was carried out to compare bronchial responses to inhaled propranolol (P) and methacholine (M) in a group of asthmatic subjects with mild to moderate bronchial hyperresponsiveness to M; to determine the short term reproducibility of bronchial response to propranolol; and to examine the shape of dose-response curve to P relative to that of M. Doses of M and P were given in mumoles and bronchial responses to both agents were expressed as the provocative dose that induced a 20 percent fall in FEV1 (PD20 FEV1). In 16 asthmatic patients, there was no correlation between the PD20 of the two agents. Mean PD20 M (+/- SD in log scale) was approximately nine times lower than mean PD20 P (0.64 +/- 0.96 and 5.80 +/- 1.65, respectively). This difference was statistically significant (t = 4.58, p less than 0.001). In six asthmatic patients, the reproducibility of PD20 P was similar to that of M (intraclass correlation coefficient 0.969 and 0.957, respectively). The shape of the dose-response curves to P was different from that of M in five of nine asthmatic patients when all experimental points were analyzed by double-reciprocal plot. We noticed that even small doses of inhaled P may cause a severe bronchoconstriction. Therefore, special caution should be taken to increase P doses very gradually, when studying the dose-response curve. We demonstrated that P inhalation induced a measurable bronchoconstriction in subjects with mild to moderate hyperresponsiveness and it was reproducible. However, the bronchial sensitivity to P was lower than to M. Our findings suggest that P and M have different mechanisms of action.