Comparative Study of Long-term Graft Survival Between Penetrating Keratoplasty and Deep Anterior Lamellar Keratoplasty

Abstract

Purpose: Endothelial failure and immunological graft rejection remain long-term complications leading to late graft failure in penetrating keratoplasty (PK). Deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK) has emerged as a viable alternative that enables preservation of the host's endothelial cells to eliminate risks of endothelial rejection and failure. The aim of this study was to compare long-term graft survival between PK and DALK.

Design: Retrospective clinical cohort study.

Methods: All consecutive primary grafts of DALKs (n = 362) and PKs (n = 307) performed for optical indications in a tertiary eye center from the ongoing, prospective Singapore Corneal Transplant Study. Ten-year graft survival outcomes were compared. Cases in which endothelial pathologies were diagnosed were excluded, as DALK was not performed for such cases. Main outcome measurements were mean graft survival rate.

Results: The survival rate for PK was 94.4%, 80.4%, and 72.0% at 1, 5, and 10 years, respectively; and 95.8%, 93.9%, and 93.9% at 1, 5, and 10 years, respectively, for DALK (P = .001). Patients who underwent PK developed more complications of glaucoma (29.3% vs. 11.6%, respectively; P < .001), allograft rejection (16.6% vs. 1.7%, respectively; P < .001), epithelial problems (10.4% vs. 5.5%, respectively; P = .018), and nonimmunological failure (7.8% vs. 1.9%, respectively; P < .001), compared to DALK. Rates of graft failure attributable to rejection (36.7% vs. 5.9%, respectively; P = .015) and endothelial failure (36.7% vs. 5.9%, respectively; P = .015) were lower in DALK.

Conclusions: The 10-year graft survival for primary DALK was superior to that for PK for corneal pathologies with functional endothelium. Primary DALK resulted in fewer post-operative complications and lower rates of graft rejection and failure. This study strengthens the case in favor of performing DALK over PK when possible.