An engineered decoy receptor for SARS-CoV-2 broadly binds protein S sequence variants

Abstract

The spike S of SARS-CoV-2 recognizes ACE2 on the host cell membrane to initiate entry. Soluble decoy receptors, in which the ACE2 ectodomain is engineered to block S with high affinity, potently neutralize infection and, due to close similarity with the natural receptor, hold out the promise of being broadly active against virus variants without opportunity for escape. Here, we directly test this hypothesis. We find an engineered decoy receptor, sACE2 ₂ .v2.4, tightly binds S of SARS-associated viruses from humans and bats, despite the ACE2-binding surface being a region of high diversity. Saturation mutagenesis of the receptor-binding domain (RBD) followed by in vitro selection, with wild type ACE2 and the engineered decoy competing for binding sites, failed to find S mutants that discriminate in favor of the wild type receptor. Variant N501Y in the RBD, which has emerged in a rapidly spreading lineage (B.1.1.7) in England, enhances affinity for wild type ACE2 20-fold but remains tightly bound to engineered sACE22.v2.4. We conclude that resistance to engineered decoys will be rare and that decoys may be active against future outbreaks of SARS-associated betacoronaviruses.

Figure 1.. SARS-associated coronaviruses have high sequence diversity at the ACE2-binding site.

The RBD of SARS-CoV-2 (PDB 6M17) is colored by diversity between 7 SARS-associated CoV strains (blue, conserved; red, variable).

Figure 2.. FACS selection for variants of S with high or low binding signal to ACE2.

(A) Flow cytometry analysis of Expi293F cells expressing full-length S of SARS-CoV-2 with an N-terminal c-myc tag. Staining for the myc-epitope is on the x-axis while the detection of bound sACE2₂-8h (2.5 nM) is on the y-axis. S plasmid was diluted 1500-fold by weight with carrier DNA so that cells typically express no more than one coding variant; under these conditions most cells are negative. (B) Flow cytometry of cells transfected with the RBD single site-saturation mutagenesis (SSM) library shows cells expressing S variants with reduced sACE2₂-8h binding. (C) Gating strategy for FACS. S-expressing cells positive for the c-myc epitope were gated (blue) and the highest (“ACE2-High”) and lowest (“ACE2-Low”) 20% of cells with bound sACE2₂-8h relative to myc-S expression were collected.

Figure 3.. Deep mutagenesis reveals that the ACE2-binding site of SARS-CoV-2 tolerates many mutations.

(A) Positional scores for surface expression are mapped to the structure of the SARS-CoV-2 RBD (PDB 6M17, oriented as in Figure 1). Blue residues in the protein core are highly conserved in the FACS selection for surface S expression (judged by depletion of mutations from the ACE2-High and ACE2-Low gates), while surface residues in red tolerate mutations. (B) Correlation plot of expression scores from mutant selection in human cells of full-length S (x-axis) versus the conservation scores (mean of the log₂ enrichment ratios at a residue position) from mutant selection in the isolated RBD by yeast display (y-axis). Notable outliers are indicated. (C) Conservation scores from the ACE2-High gated cell population are mapped to the RBD structure, with residues colored from low (blue) to high (red) mutational tolerance. (D) Correlation plot of RBD conservation scores for high ACE2 binding from deep mutagenesis of S in human cells (x-axis) versus deep mutagenesis of the RBD on the yeast surface (mean of ΔK_{D app}; y-axis).

Figure 4.. A competition-based selection to identify RBD mutations within S of SARS-CoV-2 that preferentially bind wild type or engineered ACE2 receptors.

(A) Expi293F cells were transfected with wild type myc-S and incubated with competing sACE2₂(WT)-IgG1 (25 nM) and sACE2₂.v2.4–8h (20 nM). Bound protein was detected by flow cytometry after immuno-staining for the respective epitope tags. (B) As in A, except cells were transfected with the RBD SSM library. A population of cells expressing S variants with increased specificity towards sACE2₂.v2.4 is apparent (cells shifted to the upper-left of the main population). (C) Gates used for FACS of cells expressing the RBD SSM library. After excluding cells without bound protein, the top 20% of cells for bound sACE2₂.v2.4–8h (magenta gate) and for bound sACE2₂(WT)-IgG1 (green gate) were collected. (D-E) Agreement between log₂ enrichment ratios from two independent FACS selections for cells expressing S variants with increased specificity for (D) sACE2₂(WT) or (E) sACE2₂.v2.4. R² values are calculated for nonsynonymous mutations (black). Nonsense mutations are red. (F-G) Conservation scores are calculated from the mean of the log₂ enrichment ratios for all nonsynonymous substitutions at a given residue position. Correlation plots show agreement between conservation scores for two independent selections for cells within the (D) sACE2₂(WT) or (E) sACE2₂.v2.4 specific gates.

Figure 5.. Mutations within the RBD that confer specificity towards wild type ACE2 are rare.

(A) The SARS-CoV-2 RBD is colored by specificity score (the difference between the conservation scores for cells collected in the sACE2₂(WT) and sACE2₂.v2.4 specific gates). Residues that are hot spots for mutations with increased specificity towards sACE2₂(WT) are blue or towards sACE2₂.v2.4 are purple. The contacting surface of ACE2 is shown as a green ribbon, with sites of mutations in sACE2₂.v2.4 labeled and shown as green spheres. (B) Log₂ enrichment ratios for mutations in S expressed by cell populations collected in the sACE2₂(WT) (x-axis) and sACE2₂.v2.4 (y-axis) specific gates. Data are the mean from two independent sorting experiments. S mutants in blue were predicted to have increased specificity for sACE2₂(WT) and were tested by targeted mutagenesis in Figure S6. S mutants in purple were predicted to have increased specificity for sACE2₂.v2.4 and were tested by targeted mutagenesis in Figure S7. Other nonsynonymous mutations are black. Nonsense mutations are red. (C) Wild type myc-S (grey) and three variants, Y449K (purple), N501W (light blue), and N501Y (dark blue), were expressed in Expi293F cells and tested by flow cytometry for binding to sACE2₂(WT)-8h (dashed lines) or sACE2₂.v2.4–8h (solid lines).