Clinical evaluation of a real-time inverse planning for Gamma Knife radiosurgery by convex optimization: a prospective comparative trial in a series of vestibular schwannoma patients

Abstract

Background: Gamma Knife radiosurgery (GKRS) inverse dose planning is currently far from competing effectively with the quality of dose planning developed by experienced experts. A new inverse planning (IP) method based on « efficient convex optimization algorithms » is proposed, providing high-quality dose plans in real time.

Materials and methods: Eighty-six patients treated by GKRS for vestibular schwannomas (VS) were recruited. The treatment plans created by the first author, who has 27 years of experience and has developed and delivered more than 15,000 dose plans, served as reference. A first set of basic constraints determined by default led the IP for an initial real-time dose plan. Additional constraints were interactively proposed by the planner to take other parameters into account. A second optimized plan was then calculated by the IP. The primary endpoint was the Paddick Conformity Index (PCI). The statistical analysis was planned on a non-inferiority trial design. Coverage, selectivity, and gradient indexes, dose at the organ(s) at risk, and 12 Gy isodose line volume were compared.

Results: After a single run of the IP, the PCI was shown to be non-inferior to that of the "expert." For the expert and the IP, respectively, the median coverage index was 0.99 and 0.98, the median selectivity index 0.92 and 0.90, the median gradient index 2.95 and 2.84, the median dose at the modiolus of the cochlea 2.83 Gy and 2.86 Gy, the median number of shots 14.31 and 24.13, and the median beam-on time 46.20 min and 26.77 min. In a few specific cases, advanced tools of the IP were used to generate a second run by adding new constraints either globally (for higher selectivity) or locally, in order to increase or decrease these constraints focally.

Conclusion: These preliminary results showed that this new IP method based on « efficient convex optimization algorithms », called IntuitivePlan®, provided high-quality dose plans in real time with excellent coverage, selectivity, and gradient indexes with optimized beam-on time. If the new IP evaluated here is able to compete in real time with the quality of the treatment plans of an expert with extensive radiosurgical experience, this could allow new planners/radiosurgeons with limited or no experience to immediately provide patients with high-quality GKRS for benign and malignant lesions.

Keywords: Inverse planning; Quality control; Radiosurgery; Stereotactic radiotherapy.