The osmorespiratory compromise in the fish gill

Abstract

August Krogh made fundamental discoveries about both respiratory gas exchange and osmo/iono-regulation in fish gills. Dave Randall and co-workers identified a tradeoff between these two functions such that high functional surface area and low diffusion distance would favour O₂ uptake (e.g. exercise, hypoxia), whereas low functional surface area and high diffusion distance would favour osmo/iono-regulation (rest, normoxia). Today we call this concept the "osmorespiratory compromise" and realize that it is much more complex than originally envisaged. There are at least 6 mechanisms by which fish can change functional branchial area and diffusion distance. Three involve reorganizing blood flow pathways: (i) flow redistribution within the secondary (respiratory) lamellae; (ii) flow shunting between "respiratory" and "ionoregulatory" pathways in the filament; (iii) opening up more distal lamellae on the filament and closing non-respiratory pathways. Three more involve "reversible gill remodeling": (iv) proliferation of the interlamellar gill cell mass (ILCM); (v) proliferation of ionocytes up the sides of the lamellae; (vi) covering over the apical exposure of ionocytes by extension of pavement cells. In ways that remain incompletely understood, these mechanisms allow dynamic regulation of the osmorespiratory compromise, such that ion and water fluxes can be decoupled from O₂ uptake during continuous exercise. Furthermore, hypoxia-tolerant species can reduce branchial ion and water fluxes below normoxic levels despite hyperventilating during hypoxia. In marine fish, the osmorespiratory conflict is intensified by the greater ionic and osmotic gradients from seawater to blood, but underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood.

Keywords: August Krogh; Blood-to-water diffusion distance; Functional surface area; Gills; Interlamellar cell mass; Ionocytes; Ionoregulation; Pavement cells; Respiration.