Extended lymph node resection versus standard resection for pancreatic and periampullary adenocarcinoma
- PMID: 33471373
- PMCID: PMC8094380
- DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD011490.pub2
Extended lymph node resection versus standard resection for pancreatic and periampullary adenocarcinoma
Abstract
Background: Pancreatic and periampullary adenocarcinomas account for some of the most aggressive malignancies, and the leading causes of cancer-related mortalities. Partial pancreaticoduodenectomy (PD) with negative resection margins is the only potentially curative therapy. The high prevalence of lymph node metastases has led to the hypothesis that wider excision with the removal of more lymphatic tissue could result in an improvement of survival, and higher rates of negative resection margins.
Objectives: To compare overall survival following standard (SLA) versus extended lymph lymphadenectomy (ELA) for pancreatic head and periampullary adenocarcinoma. We also compared secondary outcomes, such as morbidity, mortality, and tumour involvement of the resection margins between the two procedures.
Search methods: We searched CENTRAL, MEDLINE, PubMed, and Embase from 1973 to September 2020; we applied no language restrictions.
Selection criteria: Randomised controlled trials (RCT) comparing PD with SLA versus PD with ELA, including participants with pancreatic head and periampullary adenocarcinoma.
Data collection and analysis: Two review authors independently screened references and extracted data from study reports. We calculated pooled risk ratios (RR) for most binary outcomes except for postoperative mortality, for which we estimated a Peto odds ratio (Peto OR), and mean differences (MD) for continuous outcomes. We used a fixed-effect model in the absence of substantial heterogeneity (I² < 25%), and a random-effects model in cases of substantial heterogeneity (I² > 25%). Two review authors independently assessed risk of bias, and we used GRADE to assess the quality of the evidence for important outcomes.
Main results: We included seven studies with 843 participants (421 ELA and 422 SLA). All seven studies included Kaplan-Meier curves for overall survival. There was little or no difference in survival between groups (log hazard ratio (log HR) 0.12, 95% confidence interval (CI) -3.06 to 3.31; P = 0.94; seven studies, 843 participants; very low-quality evidence). There was little or no difference in postoperative mortality between the groups (Peto odds ratio (OR) 1.20, 95% CI 0.51 to 2.80; seven studies, 843 participants; low-quality evidence). Operating time was probably longer for ELA (mean difference (MD) 50.13 minutes, 95% CI 19.19 to 81.06 minutes; five studies, 670 participants; moderate-quality evidence). There was substantial heterogeneity between the studies (I² = 88%; P < 0.00001). There may have been more blood loss during ELA (MD 137.43 mL, 95% CI 11.55 to 263.30 mL; two studies, 463 participants; very low-quality evidence). There was substantial heterogeneity between the studies (I² = 81%, P = 0.02). There may have been more lymph nodes retrieved during ELA (MD 11.09 nodes, 95% CI 7.16 to 15.02; five studies, 670 participants; moderate-quality evidence). There was substantial heterogeneity between the studies (I² = 81%, P < 0.00001). There was little or no difference in the incidence of positive resection margins between groups (RR 0.81, 95% CI 0.58 to 1.13; six studies, 783 participants; very low-quality evidence).
Authors' conclusions: There is no evidence of an impact on survival with extended versus standard lymph node resection. However, the operating time may have been longer and blood loss greater in the extended resection group. In conclusion, current evidence neither supports nor refutes the effect of extended lymph lymphadenectomy in people with adenocarcinoma of the head of the pancreas.
Copyright © 2021 The Cochrane Collaboration. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Conflict of interest statement
RFS: none known
CS: none known
RNVdB: none known
RT: none known
JS: none known
MAP: none known
SB: none known
Figures
Update of
- doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011490
References
References to studies included in this review
Farnell 2005 {published data only}
-
- Farnell MB, Pearson RK, Sarr MG, DiMagno EP, Burgart LJ, Dahl TR, et al. A prospective randomized trial comparing standard pancreatoduodenectomy with pancreatoduodenectomy with extended lymphadenectomy in resectable pancreatic head adenocarcinoma. Surgery 2005;138(4):618-28. - PubMed
Ignjatovic 2017 {published data only}
-
- Ignjatovic I, Knezevic S, Knezevic D, Dugalic V, Micev M, Matic S, et al. Standard versus extended lymphadenectomy in radical surgical treatment for pancreatic head carcinoma. Journal of the Balkan Union of Oncology 2017;22(1):232-8. - PubMed
Jang 2014 {published data only}
-
- Jang JY, Kang JS, Han Y, Heo JS, Choi SH, Choi DW, et al. Long-term outcomes and recurrence patterns of standard versus extended pancreatectomy for pancreatic head cancer: a multicenter prospective randomized controlled study. Journal of Hepato-Biliary-Pancreatic Sciences 2017;24(7):426-33. [DOI: 10.1002/jhbp.465.] - DOI - PubMed
-
- Jang JY, Kang MJ, Heo JS, Choi SH, Choi DW, Park SJ, et al. A prospective randomized controlled study comparing outcomes of standard resection and extended resection, including dissection of the nerve plexus and various lymph nodes, in patients with pancreatic head cancer. Annals of Surgery 2014;259(4):656-64. - PubMed
Nimura 2012 {published data only}
-
- Nimura Y, Nagino M, Takao S, Takada T, Miyazaki K, Kawarada Y, et al. Standard versus extended lymphadenectomy in radical pancreatoduodenectomy for ductal adenocarcinoma of the head of the pancreas: long-term results of a Japanese multicenter randomized controlled trial. Journal of Hepato-Biliary-Pancreatic Sciences 2012;19(3):230-41. - PubMed
Pedrazzoli 1998 {published data only}
-
- Pedrazzoli S, DiCarlo V, Dionigi R, Mosca F, Pederzoli P, Pasquali C, et al. Standard versus extended lymphadenectomy associated with pancreatoduodenectomy in the surgical treatment of adenocarcinoma of the head of the pancreas: a multicenter, prospective, randomized study. Lymphadenectomy Study Group. Annals of Surgery 1998;228(4):508-17. - PMC - PubMed
Riall 2005 {published data only}
-
- Nguyen TC, Sohn TA, Cameron JL, Lillemoe KD, Campbell KA, Coleman J, et al. Standard vs. radical pancreaticoduodenectomy for periampullary adenocarcinoma: a prospective, randomized trial evaluating quality of life in pancreaticoduodenectomy survivors. Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery 2003;7(1):1-9. - PubMed
-
- Riall TS, Cameron JL, Lillemoe KD, Campbell KA, Sauter PK, Coleman J, et al. Pancreaticoduodenectomy with or without distal gastrectomy and extended retroperitoneal lymphadenectomy for periampullary adenocarcinoma-part 3: update on 5-year survival. Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery 2005;9(9):1191-206. - PubMed
-
- Yeo CJ, Cameron JL, Lillemoe KD, Sohn TA, Campbell KA, Sauter PK, et al. Pancreaticoduodenectomy with or without distal gastrectomy and extended retroperitoneal lymphadenectomy for periampullary adenocarcinoma, part 2: randomized controlled trial evaluating survival, morbidity, and mortality. Annals of Surgery 2002;236(3):355-66. - PMC - PubMed
Sperling 2016 {published data only}
-
- Sperling J, Schuld J, Hechler AM, Slotta JE, Kollmar O. Extended versus standard lymphadenectomy in patients undergoing pancreaticoduodenectomy for periampullary adenocarcinoma: a prospective randomized single center trial. European Surgery 2016;48(1):26-33.
References to studies excluded from this review
Aimoto 2013 {published data only}
-
- Aimoto T, Mizutani S, Kawano Y, Matsushita A, Yamashita N, Suzuki H, et al. Left posterior approach pancreaticoduodenectomy with total mesopancreas excision and circumferential lymphadenectomy around the superior mesenteric artery for pancreatic head carcinoma. Journal of Nippon Medical School 2013;80(6):438-45. - PubMed
Bottger 1997 {published data only}
-
- Bottger T, Boddin J, Kuchle R, Junginger T. Does the extent of lymph node dissection have an effect on morbidity and prognosis after resection of the head of the pancreas for ductal or periampullary pancreatic carcinoma? [Hat das Ausmaß der Lymphknotendissektion einen Einfluß auf die Morbidität und Prognose nach Pankreaskopfresektion wegen eines duktalen oder periampullaren Pankreaskarzinoms?]. Langenbecks Archiv fur Chirurgie 1997;382(4):209-15. - PubMed
Gazzaniga 2001 {published data only}
-
- Gazzaniga GM, Cappato S, Papadia F, Mori L, Filauro M. D1 versus D2 pancreatoduodenectomy in surgical therapy of pancreatic head cancer. Hepato-Gastroenterology 2001;48(41):1471-8. - PubMed
Henne‐Bruns 1998 {published data only}
-
- Henne-Bruns D, Vogel I, Luttges J, Kloppel G, Kremer B. Ductal adenocarcinoma of the pancreas head: survival after regional versus extended lymphadenectomy. Hepato-Gastroenterology 1998;45(21):855-66. - PubMed
Henne‐Burns 2000 {published data only}
-
- Henne-Bruns D, Vogel I, Luttges J, Kloppel G, Kremer B. Surgery for ductal adenocarcinoma of the pancreatic head: staging, complications, and survival after regional versus extended lymphadenectomy. World Journal of Surgery 2000;24(5):595-602. - PubMed
Iacono 2002 {published data only}
-
- Iacono C, Accordini S, Bortolasi L, Facci E, Zamboni G, Montresor E, et al. Results of pancreaticoduodenectomy for pancreatic cancer: extended versus standard procedure. World Journal of Surgery 2002;26(11):1309-14. - PubMed
Kawabata 2012 {published data only}
-
- Kawabata Y, Tanaka T, Nishi T, Monma H, Yano S, Tajima Y. Appraisal of a total meso-pancreatoduodenum excision with pancreaticoduodenectomy for pancreatic head carcinoma. European Journal of Surgical Oncology 2012;38(7):574-9. - PubMed
Paiella 2017 {published data only}
-
- Paiella S, Butturini G, Bassi C. Different ideas of nodal grouping in standard and extended lymphadenectomy during pancreaticoduodenectomy for pancreatic head cancer. Annals of Surgery 2017;265(6):e73-4. - PubMed
Schniewind 2006 {published data only}
-
- Schniewind B, Bestmann B, Henne-Bruns D, Faendrich F, Kremer B, Kuechler T. Quality of life after pancreaticoduodenectomy for ductal adenocarcinoma of the pancreatic head. British Journal of Surgery 2006;93(3):1099-107. - PubMed
Takao 2008 {published data only}
-
- Takao S, Shinchi H, Maemura K, Kurahara H, Natsugoe S, Aikou T. Survival benefit of pancreaticoduodenectomy in a Japanese fashion for a limited group of patients with pancreatic head cancer. Hepato-Gastroenterology 2008;55(86-87):1789-95. - PubMed
References to ongoing studies
NCT02928081 {published data only}
-
- NCT02928081. Standard versus extended lymphadenectomy in pancreatoduodenectomy for patients with pancreatic head adenocarcinoma. clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02928081 (first posted 7 October 2016).
Additional references
Adler 2007
-
- Adler G, Seufferlein T, Bischoff SC, Brambs HJ, Feuerbach S, Grabenbauer G, et al. S3 – Guidelines 'Exocrine pancreatic cancer' 2007 [S3 – Leitlinie 'Exokrines Pankreaskarzinom' 2007 – Ergebnis einer evidenzbasierten Konsensuskonferenz (13.-14.10.2006)]. Zeitschrift fur Gastroenterologie 2007;45(6):487-523. - PubMed
Alexakis 2004
-
- Alexakis N, Halloran C, Raraty M, Ghaneh P, Sutton R, Neoptolemos JP. Current standards of surgery for pancreatic cancer. British Journal of Surgery 2004;91(11):1410-27. - PubMed
Bilimoria 2009
Boyle 1989
-
- Boyle P, Hsieh CC, Maisonneuve P, La Vecchia C, Macfarlane GJ, Walker AM, et al. Epidemiology of pancreas cancer. International Journal of Pancreatology 1989;5(4):327-46. - PubMed
Buchler 2003
-
- Buchler MW, Wagner M, Schmied BM, Uhl W, Friess H, Z'graggen K. Changes in morbidity after pancreatic resection: toward the end of completion pancreatectomy. Archives of Surgery 2003;138(12):1310-4. - PubMed
Ceyhan 2006
Ceyhan 2008
-
- Ceyhan GO, Demir IE, Altintas B, Rauch U, Thiel G, Müller MW, et al. Neural invasion in pancreatic cancer: a mutual tropism between neurons and cancer cells. Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 2008;374(3):442-7. - PubMed
Dasari 2015
Fortner 1973
-
- Fortner JG. Regional resection of cancer of the pancreas: a new surgical approach. Surgery 1973;73(2):307-20. - PubMed
Fortner 1984
GRADEpro GDT [Computer program]
-
- McMaster University (developed by Evidence Prime) GRADEpro GDT: GRADEpro Guideline Development Tool [Software]. Version accessed prior to 3 November 2020. Hamilton (ON): McMaster University (developed by Evidence Prime), 2020. Available at gradepro.org.
Hackert 2011
Hariharan 2008
Higgins 2011
-
- Higgins JPT, Green S, editor(s). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.0.1 (updated March 2011). The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. Available from training.cochrane.org/handbook/archive/v5.1.
Huang 2018
-
- Huang L, Jansen L, Balavarca Y, Babaei M, Geest L, Lemmens V, et al. Stratified survival of resected and overall pancreatic cancer patients in Europe and the USA in the early twenty-first century: a large, international population-based study. BMC Medicine 2018;16(1):125. [DOI: 10.1186/s12916-018-1120-9] - DOI - PMC - PubMed
Jemal 2011
-
- Jemal A, Bray F, Center MM , Ferlay J, Ward E, Forman D. Global cancer statistics. CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians 2011;61(2):69-90. - PubMed
Kameda 1999
-
- Kameda K, Shimada H, Ishikawa T, Takimoto A, Momiyama N, Hasegawa S, et al. Expression of highly polysialylated neural cell adhesion molecule in pancreatic cancer neural invasive lesion. Cancer Letters 1999;137(2):201-7. - PubMed
Kang 2016
-
- Kang MJ, Jang JY, Kim SW. Surgical resection of pancreatic head cancer: what is the optimal extent of surgery? Cancer Letters 2016;382(2):259-65. - PubMed
Kaplan 1958
-
- Kaplan EL, Meier P. Nonparametric estimation from incomplete observations. Journal of the Americal Statistical Association 1958;53(282):457–81.
Kausch 1912
-
- Kausch W. Carcinoma of the duodenal papilla and its radical excision [Das carcinom der papilla duodeni und seine radikale entferung]. Beitrage zur klinischen Chirurgie 1912;78:439-86.
Kayahara 1995
-
- Kayahara M, Nagakawa T, Ueno K, Ohta T, Tsukioka Y, Miyazaki I. Surgical strategy for carcinoma of the pancreas head area based on clinicopathologic analysis of nodal involvement and plexus invasion. Surgery 1995;117(6):616-23. - PubMed
Manabe 1989
-
- Manabe T, Ohshio G, Baba N, Miyashita T, Asano N, Tamura K, et al. Radical pancreatectomy for ductal cell carcinoma of the head of the pancreas. Cancer 1989;64(5):1132-7. - PubMed
Michalski 2007
-
- Michalski CW, Kleeff J, Wente MN, Diener MK, Büchler MW, Friess H. Systematic review and meta-analysis of standard and extended lymphadenectomy in pancreaticoduodenectomy for pancreatic cancer. British Journal of Surgery 2007;94(3):265-73. - PubMed
Modolell 1999
-
- Modolell I, Guarner L, Malagelada JR. Vagaries of clinical presentation of pancreatic and biliary tract cancer. Annals of Oncology 1999;10(Suppl 4):82-4. - PubMed
Nagakawa 1996
-
- Nagakawa T, Nagamori M, Futakami F, Tsukioka Y, Kayahara M, Ohta T, et al. Results of extensive surgery for pancreatic carcinoma. Cancer 1996;77(4):640-5. - PubMed
Nitecki 1995
Orci 2015
-
- Orci LA, Meyer J, Combescure C, Bühler L, Berney T, Morel P, et al. A meta-analysis of extended versus standard lymphadenectomy in patients undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy for pancreatic adenocarcinoma. HPB: The Official Journal of the International Hepato Pancreato Biliary Association 2015;17(7):565-72. - PMC - PubMed
Pawlik 2005
-
- Pawlik TM, Abdalla EK, Barnett CC, Ahmad SA, Cleary KR, Vauthey JN, et al. Feasibility of a randomized trial of extended lymphadenectomy for pancreatic cancer. Archives of Surgery 2005;140(6):584-91. - PubMed
Poisot 2011
-
- Poisot T. The digitize package: extracting numerical data from scatterplots. The R Journal 2011;3(1):25-6.
Porta 2005
-
- Porta M, Fabregat X, Malats N, Guarner L, Carrato A, Miguel A, et al. Exocrine pancreatic cancer: symptoms at presentation and their relation to tumour site and stage. Clinical and Translational Oncology 2005;7(5):189-97. - PubMed
Review Manager 2014 [Computer program]
-
- Nordic Cochrane Centre, The Cochrane Collaboration Review Manager 5. Copenhagen: Nordic Cochrane Centre, The Cochrane Collaboration, 2014.
Schwarz 2014
-
- Schwarz L, Lupinacci RM, Svrcek M, Lesurtel M, Bubenheim M, Vuarnesson H, et al. Para-aortic lymph node sampling in pancreatic head adenocarcinoma. British Journal of Surgery 2014;101(5):530-8. - PubMed
Siegel 2012
-
- Siegel R, Naishadham D, Jemal A. Cancer statistics 2012. CA: a Cancer Journal for Clinicians 2012;62(1):10-29. - PubMed
Sun 2014
-
- Sun J, Yang Y, Wang X, Yu Z, Zhang T, Song J, et al. Meta-analysis of the efficacies of extended and standard pancreatoduodenectomy for ductal adenocarcinoma of the head of the pancreas. World Journal of Surgery 2014;38(10):2708-15. - PubMed
Svoronos 2014
-
- Svoronos C, Tsoulfas G, Katsourakis A, Noussios G, Chatzitheoklitos E, Marakis NG. Role of extended lymphadenectomy in the treatment of pancreatic head adenocarcinoma: review and meta-analysis. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Surgery 2014;84(10):706-11. - PubMed
Tierney 2007
Tol 2014
Traverso 1980
Valls 2002
-
- Valls C, Andía E, Sanchez A, Fabregat J, Pozuelo O, Quintero JC, et al. Dual-phase helical CT of pancreatic adenocarcinoma: assessment of resectability before surgery. American Journal of Roentgenology 2002;178(4):821-6. - PubMed
Whipple 1935
Xu 2013
Xu 2015
Yeo 1997
Yeo 2002
-
- Yeo CJ, Cameron JL, Lillemoe KD, Sohn TA, Campbell KA, Sauter PK, et al. Pancreaticoduodenectomy with or without distal gastrectomy and extended retroperitoneal lymphadenectomy for periampullary adenocarcinoma, part 2: randomized controlled trial evaluating survival, morbidity, and mortality. Annals of Surgery 2002;236(3):355-66. - PMC - PubMed
Zhang 2008
-
- Zhang J, Dhakal I, Ning B, Kesteloot H. Patterns and trends of pancreatic cancer mortality rates in Arkansas, 1969-2002: a comparison with the US population. European Journal of Cancer Prevention 2008;17(1):18-27. - PubMed
Publication types
MeSH terms
LinkOut - more resources
Full Text Sources
Other Literature Sources
Medical
