Learning curve for radiofrequency ablation of benign thyroid nodules

Abstract

Objective: To evaluate the effect of operator experience on the treatment outcomes of radiofrequency ablation (RFA) for benign thyroid nodules (BTN). Methods: Data from the 90 first RFA procedures of a single operator in treating benign thyroid nodules were prospectively collected and retrospectively analyzed. Patients were divided into 3 groups according to their chronological treatment rank: patients 1-30 (G1), 31-60 (G2) and 61-90 (G3). Clinical symptoms, volume reduction ratio (VRR), technique efficacy (TE) defined as a VRR > 50% and ablation ratio (AR) were compared between the three groups at 6 months follow-up. All complications and side effects were recorded. Results: No significant difference was observed in improvement of clinical symptoms after the RFA procedure between the three groups, with higher satisfaction however for pressure symptoms than for esthetic complaints (complete resolution 87.5% and 52.6%, respectively). In groups 1, 2 and 3, TE was 60%, 93.3%, 76.7%, VRR 54%, 65%, 60% and AR 13.1%, 34%, 34.6%, respectively. Thus, all ultrasound efficacy parameters (TE, VRR, AR) improved significantly between G1 and G2, with no difference between G2 and G3. Solely did AR improve in nodules ≤ 30 mL between G2 and G3 to reach a median value of 94.4% in G3 versus 57.1% in G2 and 13.7% in G1. Maximum values of TE and VRR (95.6% and 68%, respectively) were seen in nodules ≤ 30 mL in G2 at 6 months follow-up, with no improvement in G3 (84.2% and 63%, respectively). Both baseline volume and energy per volume were independently associated with VRR and AR. Three minor complications were recorded which all recovered totally after conservative treatment. Conclusion: There was a measurable learning curve in RFA for benign thyroid nodules regarding efficacy until 90 patients. VRR and AR can be used as proficiency markers. Only three transient complications occurred confirming the safety of the procedure.

Keywords: Learning curve; ablation techniques; minimally invasive techniques; radiofrequency ablation; thyroid nodules.