How I Do It: Pilot Study of Video-Based Feedback as an Educational Tool for Medical Students' Presentations on Morning Rounds

Abstract

Objective: Morning rounds are a bedrock learning opportunity during clinical rotations in medical school. Specific feedback is critical for students to improve presentation skills and build confidence, however, current feedback mechanisms are fragmented and nonstandard. We aimed to assess whether video-based coaching of morning rounds could improve student feedback and self-awareness without increasing anxiety during patient presentations.

Design: Medical students during core clinical clerkships were filmed presenting on morning rounds during their surgery clerkship. A designated faculty coach reviewed the video prior to an in-person coaching session. Students reviewed the video with faculty and were coached on content, presentation style, and presence. A short survey assessed students' pre- and postcoaching confidence, skill, and the utility of the coaching session.

Setting: University of Michigan Health System, Department of Surgery, Division of General Surgery, Ann Arbor, Michigan PARTICIPANTS: Eight medical student volunteers during their core clinical clerkships at University of Michigan Medical School during the surgery clerkship.

Results: Comparison of pre- and post self-assessments showed that students underestimated their knowledge of basic and clinical science and overestimated their clinical assessment skills and ability to appropriately address the core components of a presentation. Most students (75%) did not think that the filming process altered their performance and only 25% of students felt increased anxiety due to filming. All students agreed that the feedback session was useful and helped them understand how to improve their oral presentations.

Conclusion: This pilot demonstrates the feasibility and value of video-based coaching as an educational tool for medical students on clerkships. A larger sample size is needed to further evaluate the effectiveness of video-based coaching in establishing baseline clinical abilities and identifying potential areas for improvement.

Keywords: education; innovation; patient presentations; rounds; video-based coaching.