Body size preferences for women and adolescent girls living in Africa: a mixed-methods systematic review

Abstract

Objective: To synthesise evidence on body size preferences for females living in Africa and the factors influencing these.

Design: Mixed-methods systematic review including searches on Medline, CINHAL, ASSIA, Web of Science and PsycINFO (PROSPERO CRD42015020509). A sequential-explanatory approach was used to integrate quantitative and qualitative findings.

Setting: Urban and rural Africa.

Participants: Studies of both sexes providing data on body size preferences for adolescent girls and women aged ≥10 years.

Results: Seventy-three articles from twenty-one countries were included: fifty quantitative, fifteen qualitative and eight mixed methods. Most studies reported a preference for normal or overweight body sizes. Some studies of adolescent girls/young women indicated a preference for underweight. Factors influencing preferences for large(r) body sizes included: socio-demographic (e.g. education, rural residency), health-related (e.g. current BMI, pubertal status), psycho-social (e.g. avoiding HIV stigma) and socio-cultural factors (e.g. spouse's preference, social standing, cultural norms). Factors influencing preferences for slim(mer) body sizes included: socio-demographic (e.g. higher socioeconomic status, urban residency, younger age), health-related (e.g. health knowledge, being nulliparous), psycho-social (e.g. appearance, body size perception as overweight/obese) and socio-cultural factors (e.g. peer pressure, media).

Conclusions: Preference for overweight (not obese) body sizes among some African females means that interventions need to account for the array of factors that maintain these preferences. The widespread preference for normal weight is positive in public health terms, but the valorisation of underweight in adolescent girls/young women may lead to an increase in body dissatisfaction. Emphasis needs to be placed on education to prevent all forms of malnutrition.

Keywords: Adolescent girls; Africa; Body size preferences; Review; Women.

Fig. 1

Visual model for mixed methods sequential explanatory design procedures

Fig. 2

Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses flow diagram showing the selection of studies for the present systematic mixed-methods review

Fig. 3

Map displaying the African countries included in the review

Fig. 4

Body size ideals for African women and adolescent girls

Fig. 5

Integrated map of the factors influencing body size preferences for African women and adolescent girls