Competency frameworks for nurse practitioner residency and fellowship programs: Comparison, analysis, and recommendations

Abstract

Nurse practitioner (NP) education has followed the pattern of other health professions in recent years to place an emphasis on competency-based education. In recent years, postgraduate NP residency/fellowship programs to achieve competence and successful transition to practice have emerged and flourished. Currently, there is no standard competency framework in use for NP residency/fellowship programs in the United States, despite numerous published frameworks available. This article aimed to provide a comprehensive analysis of competency frameworks for NP education and to summarize and compare the competency frameworks used in NP education and residency/fellowship programs. Recommendations were sought for standardization of these competencies to create consistent evaluation and outcome measurements. Seven competency frameworks used across NP education and residency/fellowship programs were reviewed and compared in table format. Commonalities, differences, and themes were extracted from this comparison. There were more similarities than differences between the competency frameworks; however, common themes emerged as the emphasis on patient-centered, evidence-based practice, systems-based and quality improvement, and interprofessional practice and teamwork. The American Association of Colleges of Nursing Common Advanced Practice Registered Nurse Doctoral-Level Competencies, published in 2017, provided the most current, inclusive, comprehensive, and complete set of competencies for NPs at the time of graduation; however, they have not defined a progression indicator for postgraduate NP competency evaluation. This review of the competencies emphasizes (a) the need for consistent and consensus-based standards and (b) areas that NP education and residency/fellowship programs can strengthen to assess their ability to describe observable, measurable competencies. Instruments to evaluate competencies are recommended.