Medicolegal Aspects of Huntington Disease

Abstract

Unlawful behaviors have been reported in association with Huntington's disease (HD), although their overall prevalence and clinical significance remain unknown. Recognition of problematic behavior is limited by stigma and lack of routine clinical assessment, as well as the absence of validated screening measures. We performed a retrospective chart review of 289 patients treated for HD at Vanderbilt University Medical Center from 2006 to 2020 to assess the frequency of illegal activity in our HD population. We identified 31 patients with HD who have a documented history of unlawful behavior, comprising 11 percent of the charts reviewed. Physical violence was the most common behavior reported, followed by reckless driving, substance abuse, illegal financial activity, and inappropriate sexual behavior. Mean age at the time of the first offense was 37 years. Patients with criminal offenses were more likely to be male and in the early stages of disease with associated psychiatric symptoms. Our results emphasize that illegal activities are a significant clinical problem in individuals with HD, particularly young adult males with comorbid psychiatric symptoms. These findings highlight the need for improved screening measures to detect high-risk behaviors in individuals with HD, as well as evidence-based protocols to guide triage and management of patients engaging in potentially detrimental activities.

Keywords: Huntington disease; criminal behavior; impulsivity; retrospective review.