Geographical distribution and social determinants of Tobacco 21 policy adoption and retail inspections in the United States, 2015-2019

Abstract

Introduction: Tobacco control laws that raise the minimum age of tobacco sales to 21 years (T21) play a pivotal role in youth tobacco prevention, yet empirical data are sorely needed to inform enforcement, compliance efforts, and future legislation.

Methods: Spatial analysis was conducted at the zip code level by geocoding the states and localities that adopted T21 ordinances from 2015 to 2019. A multi-level logistic regression model was conducted to examine disparities in neighborhood socioeconomic status (SES), FDA retail inspection, and state-level tobacco control policies associated with T21 adoption.

Results: T21 adoption at the state and local level increased considerably from 1.4% of zip codes in 2015 to 40.2% in 2019. However, the T21 ordinances were disproportionally adopted in New England (82.6%) and Pacific (73.6%) regions with scarce coverage in East South Central (<0.1%), Mountain (1.6%), and West North Central regions (6.1%). The T21 policies were more likely to be adopted in areas with stronger tobacco control policies, urban areas (vs rural, adjusted odds ratio, AOR=1.25, p=0.005), areas with a larger Hispanic (AOR=1.19, p<0.0001) or Asian population (AOR=1.12, p<0.0001), and in areas where the population had higher levels of education (AOR=1.05, p<0.0001). It was less likely to be adopted in areas with larger proportions of American Indians, youths, and young adults. Nearly 40% of zip codes with tobacco retailers did not receive annual FDA tobacco retail inspections for underage sales in 2019. The average retail violation rate of underage sales of tobacco products in T21 regions was lower than in non-T21 regions.

Conclusions: Disparities in T21 adoption, retail inspections, and retail compliance may limit the policy impact. Unified enforcement of youth tobacco access restrictions with resources and interventions in vulnerable communities is needed to reduce tobacco-related health disparities.

Keywords: Tobacco 21; disparities; social determinant.