Individualized risk trajectories for iron-related adverse outcomes in repeat blood donors

Abstract

Background: Despite a fingerstick hemoglobin requirement and 56-day minimum donation interval, repeat blood donation continues to cause and exacerbate iron deficiency.

Study design and methods: Using data from the REDS-II Donor Iron Status Evaluation study, we developed multiclass prediction models to estimate the competing risk of hemoglobin deferral and collecting blood from a donor with sufficient hemoglobin but low or absent underlying iron stores. We compared models developed with and without two biomarkers not routinely measured in most blood centers: ferritin and soluble transferrin receptor. We generated and analyzed "individual risk trajectories": estimates of how each donors' risk developed as a function of the time interval until their next donation attempt.

Results: With standard biomarkers, the top model had a multiclass area under the receiver operator characteristic curve (AUC) of 77.6% (95% CI [77.3%-77.8%]). With extra biomarkers, multiclass AUC increased to 82.8% (95% CI [82.5%-83.1%]). In the extra biomarkers model, ferritin was the single most important variable, followed by the donation interval. We identified three risk archetypes: "fast recoverers" (<10% risk of any adverse outcome on post-donation day 56), "slow recoverers" (>60% adverse outcome risk on day 56 that declines to <35% by day 250), and "chronic high-risk" (>85% risk of the adverse outcome on day 250).

Discussion: A longer donation interval reduced the estimated risk of iron-related adverse outcomesfor most donors, but risk remained high for some. Tailoring safeguards to individual risk estimates could reduce blood collections from donors with low or absent iron stores.

Keywords: blood donation; ferritin; hemoglobin; iron deficiency.