Difference in structure between type b and nontypable Haemophilus influenzae populations

Abstract

The extent of chromosomal genetic variability and the genetic structure of Haemophilus influenzae populations was analyzed. A total of 119 isolates from humans in Göteborg, Sweden, and Birmingham, Ala., and 16 strains from a type culture collection were characterized for capsular type, biotype, outer membrane protein profile, and enzyme electrophoretic type (ET). The results of this study indicate that the bacteria identified as H. influenzae are a genetically extremely variable array of organisms. For the six enzymes studied, the estimated mean genetic diversity was 0.57 (approximately 20% higher than the corresponding estimate for Escherichia coli). Two lines of evidence indicate that despite its ability to recombine by transformation, H. influenzae maintains a largely clonal population structure. Although there is considerable potential for generating different genotypes, there were only 88 distinct ETs among the 135 strains, and isolates of the same ET and biotype were recovered at frequencies greater than would be anticipated at random. This evidence for a clonal population structure holds for uncapsulated as well as capsulated strains. However, these data also suggest that the stability of H. influenzae clones (clone persistence time) may be less than that of the nontransforming species E. coli. The ET data indicate that there is somewhat less variability among H. influenzae strains that express the same capsular antigens, biotype, and outer membrane proteins than among randomly chosen isolates. Nevertheless, there is substantial genetic variation among isolates within each of these classes and combinations thereof. There is also variation in these typing characteristics among strains of the same ET. These observations and those on genetic variability and population structures have implications for the characterization of H. influenzae isolates in clinical and epidemiological studies.