Skip to main page content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
Meta-Analysis
. 2022 Jan:97:106194.
doi: 10.1016/j.ijsu.2021.106194. Epub 2021 Dec 24.

Ablative therapies versus partial nephrectomy for small renal masses - A systematic review and meta-analysis

Vinson Wai-Shun Chan  1 , Ahmad Abul, Filzah Hanis Osman, Helen Hoi-Lam Ng, Kaiwen Wang, Yuhong Yuan, Jon Cartledge, Tze Min Wah
Affiliations
Meta-Analysis

Ablative therapies versus partial nephrectomy for small renal masses - A systematic review and meta-analysis

Vinson Wai-Shun Chan et al. Int J Surg. 2022 Jan.

Abstract

Background: High quality studies and reviews on the management of small renal masses (SRM) are lacking. This review aims to compare oncological outcomes in patients undergoing ablative therapies (AT) or partial nephrectomy (PN) for T1a or T1b SRM.

Material and methods: Medline, EMBASE, Cochrane CENTRAL and conference proceedings were searched on the 15th July 2020 for comparative studies respective to our research question. The ROBINS-I tool and the GRADE approach were used to assess any risk of biases and certainty of evidence in the included studies. The review is registered on PROSPERO.

Results: 1,748 records were retrieved. 32 observational studies and 1 RCT integrating 74,946 patients were included. Patients undergoing AT patients are significantly older than PN patients (MD 5.70, 95%CI 3.83-7.58). In T1a patients, AT patients have significantly worse overall survival (HR 1.64, 95%CI 1.39-1.95). Local recurrence-free survival is similar with PN in patients with longer than five-years follow up (HR 1.54, 95%CI 0.88-2.71). AT patients also have similar cancer-specific survival (CSS), metastasis-free survival, disease-free survival, significantly fewer post-operative complications (RR 0.72, 95%CI 0.55-0.94), and a smaller decline in estimated glomerular filtration rate post-operatively (MD: -7.42, 95%CI -13.1 to -1.70) compared to those undergoing PN. Evidence contradicts in T1b patients for oncological outcomes.

Conclusions: AT have similar long-term oncological durability; lower rates of complications and superior kidney function preservation compared to PN. Given the low quality of evidence, AT is a reasonable alternative to PN in frail and co-morbid patients. Long-term high-quality studies are needed to confirm the potential benefits of AT, especially in T1b patients.

Prospero registration: CRD42020199099.

Keywords: Ablation; Cryoablation; Partial nephrectomy; Radio-frequency ablation; Renal cell carcinoma; Small renal mass.

PubMed Disclaimer

Comment in

References

    1. Volpe A, Panzarella T, Rendon RA, Haider MA, Kondylis FI, Jewett MA. The natural history of incidentally detected small renal masses. Cancer . 2004;100(4):738-745. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/cncr.20025 .
    1. Tsui KH, van Ophoven A, Shvarts O, Belldegrun A. Nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma. Rev. Urol . 1999;1(4):216-225.
    1. Mir MC, Derweesh I, Porpiglia F, Zargar H, Mottrie A, Autorino R. Partial nephrectomy versus radical nephrectomy for clinical T1b and T2 renal tumors: a systematic review and meta-analysis of comparative studies. Eur. Urol . 2017;71(4):606-617. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eururo.2016.08.060 .
    1. Reifsnyder JE, Ramasamy R, Ng CK, Dipietro J, Shin B, Shariat SF, et al. Laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomy: complication comparison using the Clavien system. J. Soc. Laparoendosc. Surg . 2012;16(1):38-44. http://dx.doi.org/10.4293/108680812X13291597716942 .
    1. Ha SC, Zlomke HA, Cost N, Wilson S. The past, present, and future in management of small renal masses. JAMA Oncol. 2015, 2015, 364807. http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/364807

LinkOut - more resources