Symptom clusters in chronic kidney disease and their association with people's ability to perform usual activities

Abstract

Background: People living with a long-term condition, such as chronic kidney disease (CKD), often suffer from multiple symptoms simultaneously, making symptom management challenging. This study aimed to identify symptom clusters in adults with CKD across treatment groups and investigate their association with people's ability to perform their usual activities.

Methods: We conducted a secondary analysis of both cross-sectional and longitudinal data collected as part of a national service improvement programme in 14 kidney centres in England, UK. This data included symptom severity (17 items, POS-S Renal) and the extent to which people had problems performing their usual activities (single item, EQ-5D-5L). We categorised data by treatment group: haemodialysis (n = 1,462), transplantation (n = 866), peritoneal dialysis (n = 127), or CKD without kidney replacement therapy (CKD non-KRT; n = 684). We used principal component analysis to identify symptom clusters per treatment group, and proportional odds models to assess the association between clusters and usual activities.

Results: Overall, clusters related to: lack of energy and mobility; gastrointestinal; skin; and mental health. Across groups, the 'lack of energy and mobility' clusters were associated with having problems with usual activities, with odds ratios (OR) ranging between 1.24 (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.21-1.57) for haemodialysis and 1.56 for peritoneal dialysis (95% CI, 1.28-1.90). This association was confirmed longitudinally in haemodialysis (n = 399) and transplant (n = 249) subgroups.

Implications: Our findings suggest that healthcare professionals should consider routinely assessing symptoms in the 'lack of energy & mobility' cluster in all people with CKD, regardless of whether they volunteer this information; not addressing these symptoms is likely to be related to them having problems with performing usual activities. Future studies should explore why symptoms within clusters commonly co-occur and how they interrelate. This will inform the development of cluster-level symptom management interventions with enhanced potential to improve outcomes for people with CKD.

Fig 1. Prevalence of individual symptoms, presented by treatment group; people were considered to have the symptom if they had a score of > 1 on the POS-S Renal (i.e. reported being at least slightly bothered by a symptom).

Fig 2

Symptom clusters from principal component analyses (PCA), stratified by treatment group; (a) CKD non-KRT, (b) peritoneal dialysis, (c) haemodialysis and (d) transplant. The size of the circles is proportional to the PCA loading which indicates how prominent the variable is within that cluster.