Risks to sibs of probands with neural tube defects: data for clinic populations in British Columbia

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to determine whether couples receiving genetic counselling because of a child with a neural tube defect (NTD) are a selected group and therefore not representative of the general population with respect to sib risks for NTDs. British Columbia (B.C.) provides an excellent opportunity to look at this for several reasons. Firstly, genetic counselling services are centralized. Secondly, there is virtually complete ascertainment of all infants with NTDs in the province. Thirdly, sib risks for NTDs in the general population have been derived previously [McBride, 1979] and, therefore, are available for comparison with the risks for sibships in the clinic populations. In the present study, data were available on 398 sibships in which the index case had anencephaly and/or spina bifida. In all instances, sib risks for the clinic populations did not differ significantly from those for the general population. In addition, congenital malformations other than NTDs did not occur among sibs of index cases more often than expected, based on provincial incidence data.