Microbiological Diagnosis of Osteoarticular Infections: Comparison between BacT/Alert Bottles and Schaedler Broth

Abstract

Microbiological diagnosis of osteoarticular infections (OAIs) is based on culture on several media. Experts recommend the use of liquid media, such as Schaedler broth, but many laboratories use blood culture media with automated detection instead for convenience. We aimed to evaluate the performance of culturing in BacT/Alert (bioMérieux) bottles for the microbiological diagnosis of OAI versus culturing in Schaedler broth. This prospective study was conducted on all osteoarticular specimens sent to the microbiology laboratories of the Versailles and Diaconesses Croix Saint-Simon hospitals between October 2016 and February 2017. Each sample was inoculated onto solid agar, into BacT/Alert bottles incubated for 14 days, and into a Schaedler broth incubated for 14 days with daily reading. The gold standard was defined as follow: OAI was diagnosed for a patient if at least two samples were positive for a nonskin microorganism and at least three for a cutaneous species. The times to detection were compared. A total of 1,616 specimens from 349 patients were collected. BacT/Alert bottles were significantly more sensitive than the Schaedler process for OAI diagnosis (114/135 OAI detected by BacT/Alert bottles; 91/135 OAI detected by Schaedler broth; +17.0% [95% confidence interval {CI}, 6.8%, 27.3%]; P = 0.0004). The time to detection was significantly shorter using BacT/Alert bottles (2.0 ± 2.2 days) than using Schaedler broth (4.6 ± 3.6 days, P < 0.0001). The culture of osteoarticular specimens in BacT/Alert bottles allows bacterial enrichment with an automated detection of positivity. Their use decreased detection time and increased sensitivity, making it a useful tool for the diagnosis of OAI that should be included among the recommended media. IMPORTANCE Microbiological diagnosis of OAI is based on culture on several media. French experts recommend the use of liquid media such as Schaedler broth, but many laboratories use blood culture media with automated detection in substitution because it is more convenient. We report here a prospective multicentric study evaluating the performance of culture in BacT/Alert (bioMérieux) bottles for microbiological diagnosis of OAI in comparison with culture in Schaedler broth. A total of 1,616 osteoarticular specimens from 349 patients were collected and inoculated onto agar, into BacT/Alert aerobic and anaerobic bottles, and into a Schaedler broth. BacT/Alert bottles were significantly more sensitive than the Schaedler process for OAI diagnosis (+17.0% [95% CI, 6.8%, 27.3%], P = 0.0004). The time to detection was significantly shorter for the BacT/Alert bottles (2.0 ± 2.2 days) than for Schaedler broth (4.6 ± 3.6 days, P < 0.0001). This study suggests that the use of BacT/Alert bottles should be recommended in microbiological diagnosis of OAI.

Keywords: BacT/Alert bottles; OAI; Schaedler broth; osteoarticular infection.