The Simulated Physiological Oocyte Maturation (SPOM) system in domestic animals: A systematic review

Abstract

Simulated Physiological Oocyte Maturation (SPOM) mimics in vitro the physiological events of oocyte maturation. The system uses cAMP modulators in two steps (pre IVM and IVM) and has presented promising results that are arousing the curiosity of IVF programs in different animal species, generating several papers, adaptations, and controversies worldwide. This study systematically analyses the data in the literature on the use of SPOM and compares the outcomes to the original paper (Albuz et al. Hum. Rep., 25: 2999-3011 2010), classifying them into success or failure. The PubMed, Scopus, and Google Scholar databases were searched and 22 studies were included, from which data on 26 experiments were extracted and evaluated via descriptive statistical analysis. Only experiments that assessed the blastocyst rate (BR) were considered for the success parameter, i.e. success (increase in BR) or failure (either no difference or a reduction in BR). The experiments applied the SPOM system in the following species: cattle, sheep, goats, mice, mares and cats. Three experiments (3/26) could not be evaluated for success or failure, and of the remaining, 34.7% (8/23) succeeded in improving blastocyst production. More than two-thirds (69.2%, 18/26) of experiments were conducted in cattle; of those, 86.8% (13/15) used TCM-199 as the IVM media, and 22.2% did not use forskolin or IBMX modulators as indicated in the original study. Also, 27.7% (5/18) of the experiments in cattle used the same type and dose of FSH, and 22% (4/18) used the same protein source and concentration as indicated in the original study. All experiments conducted in mice (3) kept the parameters of the original study in terms of forskolin and IBMX doses and BSA and FSH concentrations, however, they removed cilostamide from IVM. Cilostamide was used during IVM in more than half (53.8%) of all experiments, but only in cattle and sheep. Considering oocyte and embryo assessments, six experiments assessed cAMP levels and most (5/6) of these observed an increase: in cattle (2), sheep (2), and mice (1). Ten experiments evaluated the effect of SPOM on nuclear maturation, and in 90% (9/10), the SPOM system was able to arrest meiosis (cattle, sheep and mice). Thirteen experiments evaluated the total cell number (cattle, mice and sheep), and six (6/13) showed an increase. Our findings clearly indicate difficulties in reproducing the SPOM system worldwide, demonstrating that the meiosis arrest is not sufficient to ensure successful SPOM application. They also suggest that the different supplements used in the IVM medium and/or their interaction with modulators for different durations may produce a significant bias that affects experimental success.

Keywords: Blastocyst; Cattle; IVM; Pre IVM; cAMP.