Every decade counts: a narrative review of functional recovery after partial nephrectomy

Abstract

Objective: To provide a narrative review of the major advances regarding ischaemia and functional recovery after partial nephrectomy (PN), along with the ongoing controversies.

Methods: Key articles reflecting major advances regarding ischaemia and functional recovery after PN were identified. Special emphasis was placed on contributions that changed perspectives about surgical management. Priority was also placed on randomized trials of off-clamp vs on-clamp cohorts.

Results: A decade ago, 'Every minute counts' was published, showing strong correlations between duration of ischaemia and development of acute kidney injury (AKI) and chronic kidney disease after clamped PN. This reinforced perspectives that ischaemia was the main modifiable factor that could be addressed to improve functional outcomes and helped spur efforts towards reduced or zero ischaemia PN. These approaches were associated with strong functional recovery and some peri-operative risk, although they were generally safe in experienced hands. Further research demonstrated that, when parenchymal volume changes were incorporated into the analyses, ischaemia lost statistical significance, and percent parenchymal volume saved proved to be the main determinant. Cold ischaemia was confirmed to be highly protective, and limited warm ischaemia also proved to be safe. The reconstructive phase of PN, with avoidance of parenchymal devascularization, appears to be most important for functional outcomes. Randomized trials of on-clamp vs off-clamp PN have shown minimal impact of ischaemia on functional recovery.

Conclusions: The past decade has witnessed great progress regarding functional recovery after PN, with many lessons learned. However, there are still unanswered questions, including: What is the threshold of warm ischaemia at which irreversible ischaemic injury begins to develop? Are some cohorts at increased risk for AKI or irreversible ischaemic injury? and Which patients should be prioritized for zero-ischaemia PN?

Keywords: #KidneyCancer; #kcsm; #uroonc; functional recovery; kidney cancer; parenchymal mass preservation; partial nephrectomy.

Fig. 1

Functional recovery after partial nephrectomy. AKI, acute kidney injury; CKD, chronic kidney disease; DM, diabetes mellitus; GFR, glomerular filtration rate; HTN, hypertension; PN, partial nephrectomy.

Fig. 2

Determinants of new baseline GFR after partial nephrectomy. PN, partial nephrectomy.