Development and validation of a new prognostic tool for impacted maxillary canines, 'Easy box': A cone-beam computed tomographic study

Abstract

Objective: To develop a tool to facilitate simple, easy and rapid assessment of the level of difficulty in disimpaction of an impacted canine using cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT).

Design: A cross-sectional study.

Methods: A panel of four experienced orthodontists formulated a questionnaire capable of portraying the limits of a three-dimensional (3D) area around impacted maxillary canines on CBCT images, which would determine the disimpaction difficulty level. In total, 14 experienced orthodontists graded each item in the questionnaire and assigned scores in the range of 0-5. Average scores obtained outlined the limits of a 3D area, within which an impaction was deemed favourable. This area was termed 'Easy box'. The disimpaction difficulty level of 170 impacted maxillary canines was then assessed using 'Easy box' and the existing tool KPG index for convergent validation.

Results: Perfect inter-examiner agreement was obtained as evidenced by Fleiss kappa value of 0.984 for the tool 'Easy box' and 0.948 for the KPG index. There was also perfect agreement between the two methods of assessment (Cohen weighted kappa, k>0.86). The average time taken for assessment using 'Easy box' was 3.3 min compared to 8.8 min for the KPG index.

Conclusion: 'Easy box' proves to be a simple, accurate and rapid assessment tool for the prognostic evaluation of impacted canines, using CBCT images. Impacted maxillary canines with cusp tips that lie beyond the limits of the 3D 'Easy box' area with a beta angle greater than 45°, were rated to be more difficult to align.

Keywords: Easy box; cone-beam computed tomography; disimpaction difficulty level; index; maxillary canine impaction.