Residual elbow instability in children with posterior or postero-lateral elbow dislocation

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the incidence and the severity of residual elbow instability in children treated for posterior (PED) or postero-lateral (PLED) elbow dislocation. This retrospective study included all children younger than 14 years of age with a confirmed diagnosis of acute post-traumatic elbow dislocation (ED). Subjective data such as perceived pain, stiffness and impact of daily activities, and objective data such as skin lesions, surgical-site infections, and range of motion were recorded. All patients underwent the milking test, the chair sign test (CST) and the Drawer test (DT). The functional status has been rated according to the Mayo Elbow Performance Score (MEPS) and the Roberts criteria (RC). Radiographs of the injured arm were performed at the last follow-up visit to evaluate axial alignment, growth disturbances, osteoarthrosis, heterotopic calcifications, and the presence of loose intra-articular bodies. Nineteen patients with a mean age of 9 years and 5 months at the time of injury were available for review. Six patients had PED (31.6%) and 13 PLED (68.4%); in five cases (26.3%) the dislocation was simple and in 14 cases (73.7%) it was complex. None of the patients complained of subjective symptoms of elbow instability, although 2 patients had positive CST, and one of them also had positive milking test. RC and MEPS ranged from good to excellent in all patients. Clinical examination with multiple stability tests is important to detect residual elbow instability in children treated for ED as functional scores alone may underestimate the clinical picture.