Evaluating the Effect of Hypoxia on Human Adult Mesenchymal Stromal Cell Chondrogenesis In Vitro : A Systematic Review

Abstract

Human adult mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) from a variety of sources may be used to repair defects in articular cartilage by inducing them into chondrogenic differentiation. The conditions in which optimal chondrogenic differentiation takes place are an area of interest in the field of tissue engineering. Chondrocytes exist in vivo in a normally hypoxic environment and thus it has been suggested that exposing MSCs to hypoxia may also contribute to a beneficial effect on their differentiation. There are two main stages in which MSCs can be exposed to hypoxia, the expansion phase when cells are cultured, and the differentiation phase when cells are induced with a chondrogenic medium. This systematic review sought to explore the effect of hypoxia at these two stages on human adult MSC chondrogenesis in vitro. A literature search was performed on PubMed, EMBASE, Medline via Ovid, and Cochrane, and 24 studies were ultimately included. The majority of these studies showed that hypoxia during the expansion phase or the differentiation phase enhances at least some markers of chondrogenic differentiation in adult MSCs. These results were not always demonstrated at the protein level and there were also conflicting reports. Studies evaluating continuous exposure to hypoxia during the expansion and differentiation phases also had mixed results. These inconsistent results can be explained by the heterogeneity of studies, including factors such as different sources of MSCs used, donor variability, level of hypoxia used in each study, time exposed to hypoxia, and differences in culture methodology.

Keywords: chondrogenesis; hypoxia; mesenchymal stromal cells.

Figure 1

Flow chart showing the process of study selection for inclusion in this systematic review.