A comparative ultrastructural study on the nanoscale extrusomes of tintinnids (Alveolata, Ciliophora, Spirotricha) and their phylogenetic significance

Abstract

The capsules, putative extrusomes in tintinnid ciliates, are known since 1971. Based on their ultrastructure, shape, and size, five capsule types were distinguished and suggested to be of phylogenetic significance. However, detailed morphometric data and transmission electron micrographs are lacking to verify former conclusions. In the current study, comprehensive analyses of transmission electron microscopic data were performed, investigating 14 species from 13 genera and more than seven families collected in European coastal waters and in the Northeast Pacific. Our data suggest two main capsule types (large and ampulliform vs small and ellipsoidal/ovoidal) each including two subtypes characterised by their internal structures. Species groupings inferred from the capsule (sub-)types emerge also as closely related in gene trees. Additionally, the ampulliform type unites the Undellidae, Xystonellidae, and Tintinnid clade 2, while the shared possession of the small ellipsoidal type proposes a close relationship of Tintinnid clade 11 with the Rhabdonellidae and Cyttarocylididae. Thus, the capsules provide promising features to shed light on several unresolved evolutionary relationships among tintinnid genera and families; yet, information on capsules is still missing for many monophyletic groupings. Finally, we provide the first ultrastructural clues for the extrusive character of these organelles.

Keywords: Ciliates; Evolution; Extrusive organelles; Marine plankton; Morphometrics; Transmission electron microscopy.