Life-cycle assessment and techno-economic evaluation of the value chain in nutrient recovery from wastewater treatment plants for agricultural application

Abstract

The recovery of nitrogen and phosphorus is important to promote circular economy in wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). In this study, the life cycle assessment (LCA) and techno-economic assessment (TEA) of a novel pilot-scale plant aimed at recovering ammonium nitrate and struvite for subsequent application in agriculture was conducted. The nutrient recovery scheme was implemented in the sludge line of the WWTP and included (i) struvite crystallisation and (ii) ion-exchange process combined with gas permeable membrane contactor. The LCA showed that using a fertilizer solution containing the recovered nutrients was environmentally better in most of the impact categories evaluated. Ammonium nitrate was the most important environmental contributor when using the recovered fertilizer solution as a result of the high consumption of chemicals needed for its production. The TEA illustrated that the implementation of the nutrient recovery scheme in the WWTP featured a negative net present value (NPV), primarily attributed to the high consumption of chemicals (representing 30 % of the gross cost). However, the implementation of the nutrient recovery scheme in the WWTP could be economically favourable if the cost of ammonium nitrate and struvite increased to 0.68 and 0.58 €/kg, respectively. The results of this pilot-scale study highlight that nutrient recovery considering the whole value chain for fertilizer application can be an attractive full-scale alternative from a sustainability point of view.

Keywords: Circular economy; LIFE Enrich project; Nutrient recovery; Sustainable life cycle analysis; Sustainable resource management; Water resource recovery factory (WRRF).