A novel simulation model for tube thoracostomy

Abstract

Objective: Tube thoracostomy is a life-saving procedure that must be performed competently and expeditiously by emergency care providers. The primary objective of this project was to develop a simple, easily-reproducible, and realistic simulation model for tube thoracostomy placement by learners of emergency medicine.

Methods: This chest tube simulator utilizes two slabs of pork ribs with associated intercostal muscle and fascial planes to aid learners in identifying anatomic landmarks, palpating intercostal spaces, and performing blunt dissection in a manner that approximates human anatomy. Holes are cut on both sides of a 1.8-bushel capacity rectangular plastic clothing hamper, and rib slabs are secured to the hamper with zip ties or metal wire. A bed pillow with plastic cover is then placed inside of the plastic hamper to simulate lung tissue. The rib-hamper complex is then wrapped with cellophane or elastic compression bandages to further anchor the rib slabs and simulate skin and subcutaneous tissues.

Results: The initial cost of our thoracostomy model is approximately $50, much less than the $1,000-$3,000 cost for a commercial model. Although the hamper and pillow can be reused an indefinite number of times, the other components of our model must be replaced occasionally. Assuming a lifespan of 1,000 uses, our model costs approximately $1.78 per attempt, compared to $4.00 per attempt with the cheapest commercial mannequin system. In fact, assuming a longer useful lifespan for the mannequin does not substantially improve this comparison (e.g. $3.10 versus $1.77 per attempt for a 10,000 attempt lifespan for the commercial mannequin), largely due to the higher cost of commercial replacement skin pads when compared to the components consumed in our model with each attempt.

Conclusions: We describe a porcine thoracostomy model that simulates the look and feel of human ribs for purposes of tube thoracostomy training, although it could also be used for thoracentesis and thoracotomy simulation. This model is relatively cheap (costing around $50) and easy to produce within a few minutes utilizing commonly-available materials. Further study is needed to determine whether an inexpensive model like ours provides the same educational value as more expensive commercial mannequin models.

Keywords: Education; chest tube; pneumothorax; simulation; teaching; thoracostomy; training.

Figure 1.

View of the thoracostomy simulation model, showing rib slabs anchored to the plastic clothing hamper and covered with polyethylene food wrap, prior to application of the simulated “skin” layer and outer coverings.

Figure 2.

View of the thoracostomy model showing the outer elastic bandage covering (“skin”) externally, as well as a pillow surrounded by plastic bag placed within the plastic clothing hamper to simulate lung and parietal pleura.

Figure 3.

View of the thoracostomy model, showing initial incision being made through aperture in sterile field.