A Critical Appraisal of Educational Theory to Examine HBCU and Black Students' Professional Identity Formation

Abstract

Objectives: This article explores educational theories and existing literature that describe the impact of Historically Black College or University (HBCU) educational environments on Black students' personal and professional development. Literature on professional identity formation (PIF) in pharmacy education is also examined to describe the influence of HBCU pharmacy education on Black pharmacy students' PIF.

Findings: Tinto's theory of student retention, Arroyo and Gasman's HBCU educational framework, and Bank's theory of multicultural education are described, as key elements of HBCU education that foster PIF in minoritized student populations. Each of the 3 models addresses professional identity traits associated with pharmacists and pharmacy students, and this review examines the role of HBCU education in Black Doctor of Pharmacy students' development of academic competence, leadership, professional communication, and advocacy.

Summary: Existing educational frameworks and models of student retention can be applied to promote student growth, psychological safety, and feelings of belonging in minoritized student populations. By engaging these models, pharmacy training environments can support Black students and other minoritized student populations as they develop their own professional identities in the pursuit of fulfilling careers.

Keywords: Arroyo and Gasman’s HBCU-institutional theory; Bank’s Multiculturalism; Professional identity formation; Tinto’s theory of student departure.