Severe Hepatopathy in National Wilms Tumor Studies 3-5: Prevalence, Clinical Features, and Outcomes After Reintroduction of Chemotherapy

Abstract

Purpose: The safety of reintroducing chemotherapy in the pediatric renal tumor setting after severe hepatopathy (SH), including sinusoidal obstruction syndrome (SOS), is uncertain. We describe the incidence, severity, outcomes, and impact on subsequent treatment for patients with SH from National Wilms Tumor Study (NWTS) protocols 3-5.

Patients and methods: Archived charts for patients enrolled on NWTS 3-5 who met study inclusion criteria for SH by using established hepatopathy grading scales and clinical criteria were reviewed for demographics, tumor characteristics, radio- and chemotherapy details, SH-related dose modifications, and oncologic outcomes. Genomic analysis for candidate polymorphisms associated with SH was performed in 14 patients.

Results: Seventy-one of 8,862 patients (0.8%) met study inclusion criteria. The median time from therapy initiation to SH was 51 days (range, 2-293 days). Sixty percent received radiotherapy, and 56% had right-sided tumors. Grade 1-4 thrombocytopenia was noted in 70% at initial occurrence of SH (median 22,000/microliter). Among 69 of 71 children with SH occurring before the end of therapy (EOT) and post-SH treatment information available, chemotherapy was delayed posthepatopathy for 65% (69% of these at a reduced dose), continued without delay for 20% (57% of these at reduced dose), and stopped completely for 15% (4 of 10 of whom died of SH). Overall, 42% of patients with dose reductions achieved full dose by EOT. The five-year post-SH event-free survival for patients who continued therapy was 89% (95% CI, 81 to 98), with no significant differences by whether delay or dose reduction occurred. We identified no SH-associated pharmacogenomic polymorphism.

Conclusion: The incidence of SH on NWTS 3-5 was low; many had associated severe thrombocytopenia. Careful reintroduction of chemotherapy appeared to be feasible for the majority of patients who developed severe chemotherapy- and/or radiotherapy-induced liver toxicity.

FIG 1.

Flow diagram of patient inclusion. NWTS, National Wilms Tumor Study; SH, severe hepatopathy.

FIG 2.

Posthepatopathy treatment strategy diagram. EOT, end of therapy; SH, severe hepatopathy.

FIG 3.

Post-SH EFS by treatment factors. (A) Post-SH EFS among patients who resumed chemotherapy. (B) Post-SH EFS by whether resumed chemotherapy was delayed. (C) Post-SH EFS by whether resumed chemotherapy was dose-reduced. EFS, event-free survival; SH, severe hepatopathy.