Patient Dietary Supplements Use: Do Results from Natural Language Processing of Clinical Notes Agree with Survey Data?

Abstract

There is widespread use of dietary supplements, some prescribed but many taken without a physician's guidance. There are many potential interactions between supplements and both over-the-counter and prescription medications in ways that are unknown to patients. Structured medical records do not adequately document supplement use; however, unstructured clinical notes often contain extra information on supplements. We studied a group of 377 patients from three healthcare facilities and developed a natural language processing (NLP) tool to detect supplement use. Using surveys of these patients, we investigated the correlation between self-reported supplement use and NLP extractions from the clinical notes. Our model achieved an F1 score of 0.914 for detecting all supplements. Individual supplement detection had a variable correlation with survey responses, ranging from an F1 of 0.83 for calcium to an F1 of 0.39 for folic acid. Our study demonstrated good NLP performance while also finding that self-reported supplement use is not always consistent with the documented use in clinical records.

Keywords: dietary supplements; machine learning; natural language processing.

Figure 1

Methods. Notes from other patients are used to train the SVM. Notes from the survey patients are then classified on supplement use; classification output is then compared to the survey results.