Skip to main page content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
. 2023 Jul 14;9(28):eadh1003.
doi: 10.1126/sciadv.adh1003. Epub 2023 Jul 14.

Abundant presolar grains and primordial organics preserved in carbon-rich exogenous clasts in asteroid Ryugu

Ann N Nguyen  1 Prajkta Mane  2 Lindsay P Keller  1 Laurette Piani  3 Yoshinari Abe  4 Jérôme Aléon  5 Conel M O'D Alexander  6 Sachiko Amari  7   8 Yuri Amelin  9 Ken-Ichi Bajo  10 Martin Bizzarro  11 Audrey Bouvier  12 Richard W Carlson  6 Marc Chaussidon  13 Byeon-Gak Choi  14 Nicolas Dauphas  15 Andrew M Davis  15 Tommaso Di Rocco  16 Wataru Fujiya  17 Ryota Fukai  18 Ikshu Gautam  19 Makiko K Haba  19 Yuki Hibiya  20 Hiroshi Hidaka  21 Hisashi Homma  22 Peter Hoppe  23 Gary R Huss  24 Kiyohiro Ichida  25 Tsuyoshi Iizuka  26 Trevor R Ireland  27 Akira Ishikawa  19 Shoichi Itoh  28 Noriyuki Kawasaki  10 Noriko T Kita  29 Kouki Kitajima  29 Thorsten Kleine  30 Shintaro Komatani  25 Alexander N Krot  24 Ming-Chang Liu  31 Yuki Masuda  19 Kevin D McKeegan  31 Mayu Morita  25 Kazuko Motomura  32 Frédéric Moynier  13 Izumi Nakai  33 Kazuhide Nagashima  24 David Nesvorný  34 Larry Nittler  6   35 Morihiko Onose  25 Andreas Pack  16 Changkun Park  36 Liping Qin  37 Sara S Russell  38 Naoya Sakamoto  39 Maria Schönbächler  40 Lauren Tafla  31 Haolan Tang  31 Kentaro Terada  41 Yasuko Terada  42 Tomohiro Usui  17 Sohei Wada  10 Meenakshi Wadhwa  35 Richard J Walker  43 Katsuyuki Yamashita  44 Qing-Zhu Yin  45 Tetsuya Yokoyama  19 Shigekazu Yoneda  46 Edward D Young  31 Hiroharu Yui  47 Ai-Cheng Zhang  48 Tomoki Nakamura  49 Hiroshi Naraoka  50 Takaaki Noguchi  28 Ryuji Okazaki  50 Kanako Sakamoto  18 Hikaru Yabuta  51 Masanao Abe  18 Akiko Miyazaki  18 Aiko Nakato  18 Masahiro Nishimura  18 Tatsuaki Okada  18 Toru Yada  18 Kasumi Yogata  18 Satoru Nakazawa  18 Takanao Saiki  18 Satoshi Tanaka  18 Fuyuto Terui  52 Yuichi Tsuda  18 Sei-Ichiro Watanabe  21 Makoto Yoshikawa  18 Shogo Tachibana  53 Hisayoshi Yurimoto  10   38
Affiliations

Abundant presolar grains and primordial organics preserved in carbon-rich exogenous clasts in asteroid Ryugu

Ann N Nguyen et al. Sci Adv. .

Abstract

Preliminary analyses of asteroid Ryugu samples show kinship to aqueously altered CI (Ivuna-type) chondrites, suggesting similar origins. We report identification of C-rich, particularly primitive clasts in Ryugu samples that contain preserved presolar silicate grains and exceptional abundances of presolar SiC and isotopically anomalous organic matter. The high presolar silicate abundance (104 ppm) indicates that the clast escaped extensive alteration. The 5 to 10 times higher abundances of presolar SiC (~235 ppm), N-rich organic matter, organics with N isotopic anomalies (1.2%), and organics with C isotopic anomalies (0.2%) in the primitive clasts compared to bulk Ryugu suggest that the clasts formed in a unique part of the protoplanetary disk enriched in presolar materials. These clasts likely represent previously unsampled outer solar system material that accreted onto Ryugu after aqueous alteration ceased, consistent with Ryugu's rubble pile origin.

PubMed Disclaimer

Figures

Fig. 1.
Fig. 1.. Backscattered electron (BSE) image and elemental maps of a region of grain C0002 containing primitive clast 1, outlined in the BSE image.
This clast is rich in Fe and S and depleted in Mg, Si, and O compared to the surrounding matrix. It also contains Mg-rich silicate grains that are likely olivine. White arrows indicate a cluster of these grains.
Fig. 2.
Fig. 2.. Region of grain C0002 containing a portion of primitive clast 1 and hydrated Ryugu matrix.
The BSE (top left) and corresponding NanoSIMS 16O, 28Si, 24Mg16O, 12C, and 12C14N ion images show that the clast 1 matrix is more fine-grained and has a well-defined boundary with the altered Ryugu matrix. The NanoSIMS ion images show that the clast has lower 28Si signal and greater 12C and 12C14N signals relative to the neighboring matrix, indicative of a higher abundance of N-rich organic matter in the clast. The 12C14N image was acquired in a subsequent measurement, and the analysis region is shifted up by 3 μm relative to the other images. This portion of clast 1 contains 17O-rich presolar silicate C0002-C1 and 13C-rich presolar SiC grain C0002-C7, shown by the arrows in the NanoSIMS δ17O/16O and δ13C/12C ratio images. Isotope ratios are given as deviations from the standard values in per mil (‰). Small variations in the isotope ratio images are due to statistical fluctuations.
Fig. 3.
Fig. 3.. NanoSIMS and TEM data for the 17O-rich presolar grain C0002-C3.
The presolar grain is indicated by the arrow in the 17O/16O ratio image of a region of clast 1 (top left). Isotopic ratios are given as deviations from terrestrial composition in per mil (‰). The inset in the high-resolution TEM (HR-TEM) image shows diffuse scattering consistent with an amorphous structure. The bright-field STEM (BF-STEM) image and elemental maps of the presolar grain (outlined in red) show that it is a silicate with pyroxene stoichiometry and composition (Mg0.8Fe0.2)(Si, Al)O3.
Fig. 4.
Fig. 4.. Isotopic compositions and abundances of IAOM in the Ryugu matrix and primitive clasts 1 and 2.
The IAOM in the different lithologies has similar C and N isotopic distributions (A). However, the clasts have much higher abundances of IAOM [%; (B)] than the Ryugu matrix. Isotopically normal organic matter is not plotted. Errors in (A) are 1σ.
Fig. 5.
Fig. 5.. Abundances of presolar grains in Ryugu, carbonaceous chondrites, and an AMM.
Abundances of presolar silicates and oxides (O-rich), SiC, and graphite in clasts 1 and 2 and Ryugu matrix compared to abundances in chondrites of various classes [(9) and references therein (10, 18, 19, 22, 33, 36, 37, 51)] and an AMM (31). The abundances in Ryugu are consistent with CI chondrites except for clasts 1 and 2, which have remarkably high abundances of presolar SiC grains. The presolar silicate abundance in clast 1 is similar to primitive chondrites and not altered CI. Presolar O-rich grain abundances for A0040 clast 2, total Ryugu without clasts, and Ivuna (22) are upper limits. Errors are 1σ. wo, without. Not plotted are presolar grain abundances in comet Wild 2 and IDPs. The abundance of O-rich presolar grains in comet Wild 2 samples is 600 to 830 ppm, and the abundance of presolar SiC is 45 ppm (26). Anhydrous IDPs display a wide range of presolar abundances for O-rich grains (20 to 23,080 ppm including 1σ errors) and SiC grains (10 to 630 ppm including 1σ errors) (21, 27, 34, 35).

References

    1. Yokoyama T., Nagashima K., Nakai I., Young E. D., Abe Y., Aléon J., Alexander C. M. O.'. D., Amari S., Amelin Y., Bajo K.-i., Bizzarro M., Bouvier A., Carlson R. W., Chaussidon M., Choi B.-G., Dauphas N., Davis A. M., Di Rocco T., Fujiya W., Fukai R., Gautam I., Haba M. K., Hibiya Y., Hidaka H., Homma H., Hoppe P., Huss G. R., Ichida K., Iizuka T., Ireland T. R., Ishikawa A., Ito M., Itoh S., Kawasaki N., Kita N. T., Kitajima K., Kleine T., Komatani S., Krot A. N., Liu M.-C., Masuda Y., McKeegan K. D., Morita M., Motomura K., Moynier F., Nguyen A., Nittler L., Onose M., Pack A., Park C., Piani L., Qin L., Russell S. S., Sakamoto N., Schönbächler M., Tafla L., Tang H., Terada K., Terada Y., Usui T., Wada S., Wadhwa M., Walker R. J., Yamashita K., Yin Q.-Z., Yoneda S., Yui H., Zhang A.-C., Connolly H. C., Lauretta D. S., Nakamura T., Naraoka H., Noguchi T., Okazaki R., Sakamoto K., Yabuta H., Abe M., Arakawa M., Fujii A., Hayakawa M., Hirata N., Hirata N., Honda R., Honda C., Hosoda S., Iijima Y.-i., Ikeda H., Ishiguro M., Ishihara Y., Iwata T., Kawahara K., Kikuchi S., Kitazato K., Matsumoto K., Matsuoka M., Michikami T., Mimasu Y., Miura A., Morota T., Nakazawa S., Namiki N., Noda H., Noguchi R., Ogawa N., Ogawa K., Okada T., Okamoto C., Ono G., Ozaki M., Saiki T., Sakatani N., Sawada H., Senshu H., Shimaki Y., Shirai K., Sugita S., Takei Y., Takeuchi H., Tanaka S., Tatsumi E., Terui F., Tsuda Y., Tsukizaki R., Wada K., Watanabe S.-i., Yamada M., Yamada T., Yamamoto Y., Yano H., Yokota Y., Yoshihara K., Yoshikawa M., Yoshikawa K., Furuya S., Hatakeda K., Hayashi T., Hitomi Y., Kumagai K., Miyazaki A., Nakato A., Nishimura M., Soejima H., Suzuki A., Yada T., Yamamoto D., Yogata K., Yoshitake M., Tachibana S., Yurimoto H., Samples returned from the asteroid Ryugu are similar to Ivuna-type carbonaceous meteorites. Science 379, eabn7850 (2023). - PubMed
    1. Nakamura E., Kobayashi K., Tanaka R., Kunihiro T., Kitagawa H., Potiszil C., Ota T., Sakaguchi C., Yamanaka M., Ratnayake D. M., Tripathi H., Kumar R., Avramescu M.-L., Tsuchida H., Yachi Y., Miura H., Abe M., Fukai R., Furuya S., Hatakeda K., Hayashi T., Hitomi Y., Kumagai K., Miyazaki A., Nakato A., Nishimura M., Okada T., Soejima H., Sugita S., Suzuki A., Usui T., Yada T., Yamamoto D., Yogata K., Yoshitake M., Arakawa M., Fujii A., Hayakawa M., Hirata N., Hirata N., Honda R., Honda C., Hosoda S., Iijima Y.-i., Ikeda H., Ishiguro M., Ishihara Y., Iwata T., Kawahara K., Kikuchi S., Kitazato K., Matsumoto K., Matsuoka M., Michikami T., Mimasu Y., Miura A., Morota T., Nakazawa S., Namiki N., Noda H., Noguchi R., Ogawa N., Ogawa K., Okamoto C., Ono G., Ozaki M., Saiki T., Sakatani N., Sawada H., Senshu H., Shimaki Y., Shirai K., Takei Y., Takeuchi H., Tanaka S., Tatsumi E., Terui F., Tsukizaki R., Wada K., Yamada M., Yamada T., Yamamoto Y., Yano H., Yokota Y., Yoshihara K., Yoshikawa M., Yoshikawa K., Fujimoto M., S.-i. Watanabe, Tsuda Y., On the origin and evolution of the asteroid Ryugu: A comprehensive geochemical perspective. Proc. Jpn. Acad. B 98, 227–282 (2022). - PMC - PubMed
    1. Nakamura T., Matsumoto M., Amano K., Enokido Y., Zolensky M. E., Mikouchi T., Genda H., Tanaka S., Zolotov M. Y., Kurosawa K., Wakita S., Hyodo R., Nagano H., Nakashima D., Takahashi Y., Fujioka Y., Kikuiri M., Kagawa E., Matsuoka M., Brearley A. J., Tsuchiyama A., Uesugi M., Matsuno J., Kimura Y., Sato M., Milliken R. E., Tatsumi E., Sugita S., Hiroi T., Kitazato K., Brownlee D., Joswiak D. J., Takahashi M., Ninomiya K., Takahashi T., Osawa T., Terada K., Brenker F. E., Tkalcec B. J., Vincze L., Brunetto R., Aléon-Toppani A., Chan Q. H. S., Roskosz M., Viennet J. C., Beck P., Alp E. E., Michikami T., Nagaashi Y., Tsuji T., Ino Y., Martinez J., Han J., Dolocan A., Bodnar R. J., Tanaka M., Yoshida H., Sugiyama K., King A. J., Fukushi K., Suga H., Yamashita S., Kawai T., Inoue K., Nakato A., Noguchi T., Vilas F., Hendrix A. R., Jaramillo-Correa C., Domingue D. L., Dominguez G., Gainsforth Z., Engrand C., Duprat J., Russell S. S., Bonato E., Ma C., Kawamoto T., Wada T., Watanabe S., Endo R., Enju S., Riu L., Rubino S., Tack P., Takeshita S., Takeichi Y., Takeuchi A., Takigawa A., Takir D., Tanigaki T., Taniguchi A., Tsukamoto K., Yagi T., Yamada S., Yamamoto K., Yamashita Y., Yasutake M., Uesugi K., Umegaki I., Chiu I., Ishizaki T., Okumura S., Palomba E., Pilorget C., Potin S. M., Alasli A., Anada S., Araki Y., Sakatani N., Schultz C., Sekizawa O., Sitzman S. D., Sugiura K., Sun M., Dartois E., De Pauw E., Dionnet Z., Djouadi Z., Falkenberg G., Fujita R., Fukuma T., Gearba I. R., Hagiya K., Hu M. Y., Kato T., Kawamura T., Kimura M., Kubo M. K., Langenhorst F., Lantz C., Lavina B., Lindner M., Zhao J., Vekemans B., Baklouti D., Bazi B., Borondics F., Nagasawa S., Nishiyama G., Nitta K., Mathurin J., Matsumoto T., Mitsukawa I., Miura H., Miyake A., Miyake Y., Yurimoto H., Okazaki R., Yabuta H., Naraoka H., Sakamoto K., Tachibana S., Connolly H. C. Jr., Lauretta D. S., Yoshitake M., Yoshikawa M., Yoshikawa K., Yoshihara K., Yokota Y., Yogata K., Yano H., Yamamoto Y., Yamamoto D., Yamada M., Yamada T., Yada T., Wada K., Usui T., Tsukizaki R., Terui F., Takeuchi H., Takei Y., Iwamae A., Soejima H., Shirai K., Shimaki Y., Senshu H., Sawada H., Saiki T., Ozaki M., Ono G., Okada T., Ogawa N., Ogawa K., Noguchi R., Noda H., Nishimura M., Namiki N., Nakazawa S., Morota T., Miyazaki A., Miura A., Mimasu Y., Matsumoto K., Kumagai K., Kouyama T., Kikuchi S., Kawahara K., Kameda S., Iwata T., Ishihara Y., Ishiguro M., Ikeda H., Hosoda S., Honda R., Honda C., Hitomi Y., Hirata N., Hirata N., Hayashi T., Hayakawa M., Hatakeda K., Furuya S., Fukai R., Fujii A., Cho Y., Arakawa M., Abe M., Watanabe S., Tsuda Y., Formation and evolution of carbonaceous asteroid Ryugu: Direct evidence from returned samples. Science 379, eabn8671 (2023). - PubMed
    1. Ito M., Tomioka N., Uesugi M., Yamaguchi A., Shirai N., Ohigashi T., Liu M.-C., Greenwood R. C., Kimura M., Imae N., Uesugi K., Nakato A., Yogata K., Yuzawa H., Kodama Y., Tsuchiyama A., Yasutake M., Findlay R., Franchi I. A., Malley J. A., McCain K. A., Matsuda N., McKeegan K. D., Hirahara K., Takeuchi A., Sekimoto S., Sakurai I., Okada I., Karouji Y., Arakawa M., Fujii A., Fujimoto M., Hayakawa M., Hirata N., Hirata N., Honda R., Honda C., Hosoda S., Iijima Y.-i., Ikeda H., Ishiguro M., Ishihara Y., Iwata T., Kawahara K., Kikuchi S., Kitazato K., Matsumoto K., Matsuoka M., Michikami T., Mimasu Y., Miura A., Mori O., Morota T., Nakazawa S., Namiki N., Noda H., Noguchi R., Ogawa N., Ogawa K., Okada T., Okamoto C., Ono G., Ozaki M., Saiki T., Sakatani N., Sawada H., Senshu H., Shimaki Y., Shirai K., Sugita S., Takei Y., Takeuchi H., Tanaka S., Tatsumi E., Terui F., Tsukizaki R., Wada K., Yamada M., Yamada T., Yamamoto Y., Yano H., Yokota Y., Yoshihara K., Yoshikawa M., Yoshikawa K., Fukai R., Furuya S., Hatakeda K., Hayashi T., Hitomi Y., Kumagai K., Miyazaki A., Nishimura M., Soejima H., Iwamae A., Yamamoto D., Yoshitake M., Yada T., Abe M., Usui T., Watanabe S.-i., Tsuda Y., A pristine record of outer Solar System materials from asteroid Ryugu’s returned sample. Nat. Astron. 6, 1163–1171 (2022).
    1. Kawasaki N., Nagashima K., Sakamoto N., Matsumoto T., Bajo K.-i., Wada S., Igami Y., Miyake A., Noguchi T., Yamamoto D., Russell S. S., Abe Y., Aléon J., Alexander C. M. O.’. D., Amari S., Amelin Y., Bizzarro M., Bouvier A., Carlson R. W., Chaussidon M., Choi B.-G., Dauphas N., Davis A. M., Di Rocco T., Fujiya W., Fukai R., Gautam I., Haba M. K., Hibiya Y., Hidaka H., Homma H., Hoppe P., Huss G. R., Ichida K., Iizuka T., Ireland T. R., Ishikawa A., Ito M., Itoh S., Kita N. T., Kitajima K., Kleine T., Komatani S., Krot A. N., Liu M.-C., Masuda Y., McKeegan K. D., Morita M., Motomura K., Moynier F., Nakai I., Nguyen A., Nittler L., Onose M., Pack A., Park C., Piani L., Qin L., Schönbächler M., Tafla L., Tang H., Terada K., Terada Y., Usui T., Wadhwa M., Walker R. J., Yamashita K., Yin Q.-Z., Yokoyama T., Yoneda S., Young E. D., Yui H., Zhang A.-C., Nakamura T., Naraoka H., Okazaki R., Sakamoto K., Yabuta H., Abe M., Miyazaki A., Nakato A., Nishimura M., Okada T., Yada T., Yogata K., Nakazawa S., Saiki T., Tanaka S., Terui F., Tsuda Y., Watanabe S.-i., Yoshikawa M., Tachibana S., Yurimoto H., Oxygen isotopes of anhydrous primary minerals show kinship between asteroid Ryugu and comet 81P/Wild2. Sci. Adv. 8, eade2067 (2022). - PMC - PubMed