A stepwise diagnostic approach for undiagnosed Anemia in children: A model for low-middle income country

Abstract

Background: Reaching a precise diagnosis in rare inherited anemia is extremely difficult and challenging, especially in areas with limited use of genetic studies, which makes undiagnosed anemia a unique clinical entity in tertiary hematology centers. In this study, we aim at plotting a stepwise diagnostic approach in children with undiagnosed anemia while identifying indications for genetic testing.

Patients and methods: A one-year cross-sectional study involved 44 children and adolescents with undiagnosed anemia after undergoing an initial routine panel of investigations. They were classified based on mean corpuscular volume (MCV) into 3 groups: microcytic (n = 19), normocytic (n = 14) and macrocytic (n = 11). An algorithm that included four levels of investigations was devised for each category.

Results: After applying a systematic diagnostic approach, 33 patients (75 %) were diagnosed of whom 7 (15 %) had combined diagnoses, while 11 (25 %) patients remained undiagnosed. Based on the first, second, third and fourth levels of investigations, patients were diagnosed, respectively, as follows: of the 11 patients, 7 were microcytic, 3 normocytic and 1 macrocytic; of the 7 patients, 2 were microcytic, 2 normocytic, and 3 macrocytic; of 10 patients, 5 were microcytic, 4 normocytic and 1 macrocytic; finally, of the 16 patients, 8 were microcytic, 6 normocytic and 2 macrocytic. Numbers recorded appear higher than the actual number of the patients because some of them were diagnosed by more than one level of investigation. The diagnoses obtained in the microcytic group showed hemoglobinopathies, iron refractory iron deficiency anemia (IRIDA), membrane defects, sideroblastic anemia, hypo-transferrinemia, a combined diagnosis of sickle cell trait and pyropoikilocytosis. The diagnoses also showed a combined diagnosis of hereditary spherocytosis (HS) and alpha thalassemia minor, and a combined diagnosis of iron deficiency anemia and beta thalassemia minor, while 15 % remained undiagnosed. In the normocytic group, the diagnosis revealed autosomal recessive (AR) HS, vitamin B12 deficiency, pyruvate kinase deficiency (PKD), congenital dyserythropoietic anemia (CDA) type I, Diamond Blackfan anemia and beta thalassemia major. In addition, it showed a combined diagnosis of AR HS and CDA type II, a combined diagnosis of AR HS and PKD, and a combined diagnosis of dehydrated stomatocytosis (DHS) and G6PD carrier, meanwhile 20 % remained undiagnosed. Finally, the macrocytic group was diagnosed by vitamin B12 deficiency, sideroblastic anemia, PKD, a combined diagnosis of PKD and G6PD deficiency carrier, while 45 % remained undiagnosed.

Conclusion: Conducting a stepwise approach with different levels of investigations may help reach the diagnosis of difficult anemia without having to resort to unnecessary investigations. Combined diagnosis is an important cause of undiagnosed anemia, especially in countries with high frequency of consanguinity. The remaining 25 % of the patients continued to be undiagnosed, requiring more sophisticated investigations.

Keywords: CDA; PKD; Undiagnosed anemia.