Neuropsychological Differences Between Surgery Interns and Age-Matched Adults

Abstract

Objective: The purpose of this study was to assess how neuropsychological factors differ between general surgery interns and normative data from age-matched adults in the general population.

Design: Participants completed a comprehensive neuropsychological assessment battery. Neuropsychological factors assessed included: executive function (Behavioral Rating Inventory of Executive Function, BRIEF), working memory (Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale, or WAIS, digit span), psychomotor speed (WAIS coding, Trails A and B), selective attention (D2 Test of Attention), and problem solving (Tower of London, TOL). Data for all measures was compared to previously published normative data for age-matched, healthy adults in the general population using one-sample t-tests.

Setting: This study was completed at Indiana University School of Medicine in Indianapolis, IN, which is a large academic healthcare training institution.

Participants: Postgraduate year 1 general surgery residents (PGY1s) voluntarily participated in this study.

Results: Twenty-six general surgery PGY1s completed all measures. We found that PGY1s had significantly better behavioral inhibition, working memory, selective attention, problem solving, and psychomotor speed than their counterparts in the general population (Table 1). Conversely, we found that PGY1s had significantly lower cognitive flexibility (p = 0.02) and ability to monitor task progress (p = 0.006) than the general population.

Conclusions: The results from this study indicate that there are several neuropsychological factors that may help explain the high achievement of general surgery PGY1s. Assessment of these factors could aid general surgery programs in the selection and training of high-caliber residents. However, there are indicators that PGY1s struggle from cognitive inflexibility and task monitoring compared to the general population. These skills are needed to manage the complex and dynamic nature of surgical performance, so educators should consider methods to enhance junior residents' development of these characteristics.

Keywords: executive function; problem solving; residents; selective attention; working memory.