Skip to main page content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
. 2023;15(2):173-200.
doi: 10.1007/s12685-023-00329-y. Epub 2023 May 30.

Dumping military waste into Lake Superior: the historic legacies of secrecy, censorship, and uncertainty

Elodie Charrière  1   2 , Nancy Langston  1
Affiliations

Dumping military waste into Lake Superior: the historic legacies of secrecy, censorship, and uncertainty

Elodie Charrière et al. Water Hist. 2023.

Abstract

In recent years, the issue of military waste disposal in oceans and seas has gained significant attention; however, the impact of such waste in freshwater deposits has been understudied. The Laurentian Great Lakes of North America contain 20% of the world's fresh surface water and are particularly vulnerable to environmental stressors such as climate change, invasive species, and toxic chemicals, making the examination of military waste management in these waters crucial. This interdisciplinary study aims to investigate the legacy of two military waste disposal sites in Lake Superior, referred to as Site A (containing barrels) and Site B (containing bullets). Both are located within the ceded territories of the Ojibwe. Despite being in close proximity, these sites have had vastly different outcomes in terms of public concern, state and federal regulatory actions, and tribal restoration efforts. Based on this observation, this study aims to answer the following questions: How did these differences develop? How did military secrecy and the loss of memory influence the management of underwater military waste at each site? How do uncertainties and rumors continue to influence citizen concern and agency management of military waste? We argue for the importance of investigating the environmental legacies of underwater military waste in order to protect inland freshwater resources worldwide.

Keywords: Environmental history; Lake Superior; Underwater military waste; Water pollution.

PubMed Disclaimer

Conflict of interest statement

Conflict of interestThe authors declare no conflict of interest.

Figures

Fig. 1
Fig. 1
Formerly Used Defense Sites on the U.S. Side of the Great Lakes Region. Credit: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Fig. 2
Fig. 2
Two Sites in Lake Superior with Underwater Military Wastes. Site A: Barrels; Site B: Bullets
Fig. 3
Fig. 3
Barrels Dumping Areas (Site A) and Water Intakes. Credit: Bonnie Urfer, Nukewatch (2013)
See this image and copyright information in PMC

References

A. Primary sources: archives

    1. Adamkus VV, USEPA Region V (1977) Letter to Philip E. Ruppe, Congressman, January. John Pegors collection, S6095, Box 11. Kathryn A. Martin Library & Archives (KAML&A), University of Minnesota, Duluth (MN)
    1. Defense Environmental Restoration Program for Formerly Used Defense Sites (DERP-FUDS) (1991) Project Summary Sheet, Lake Superior—Classified Scrap Disposal n°E05MN025503. Lake Superior records, E05MN0255. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), Omaha District
    1. Federal Cartridge Corporation (FCC) (1946) Historical Report of Twin Cities Ordnance Plant, October 1, 1945—December 31, 1945. Twin Cities Arsenal, Minneapolis-St. Paul, Minnesota, RG 156, Location 348/915830–915836, Box 15. National Archives (NARA) Chicago (IL)
    1. Gardebring SS, Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (1977) Certificate of Agency’s Authorizing Resolution, December 15. Investigation file about the barrels dumped into Lake Superior. Marilyn Burton Personal Records, Sault Ste Marie (MI)
    1. Liverman JL, U.S. Energy Research and Development (1976) Letter to Howard A. Tanner, Director Department of Natural Resources, State of Michigan, December 7. Investigation file about the barrels dumped into Lake Superior. Marilyn Burton Personal Records, Sault Ste Marie (MI)

B. Primary sources: newspapers

    1. Cook County News Herald (2022) Red Cliff Band continues to be stalled in their efforts to remove barrels of military waste from Lake Superior, Feb 28, 2022. https://www.cookcountynews-herald.com/articles/red-cliff-band-continues-.... Accessed 7 Nov 2022
    1. Dean PR (1959) Disposition form to Commanding Officer Chicago Ordnance District, September 22. Disposal of Scrap Material. In: Final Report on Classified Scrap in Lake Superior, U.S. Army Armament Materiel Readiness Command (ARMCOM) (1977). Rock Island IL
    1. Duluth Herald (1945) Unused cartridges dumped into lake. Sept 28, 63(146):7
    1. Duluth News-Tribune (2013) Short news: briefing set for Thursday about Lake Superior barrels, Mar 2. https://www.duluthnewstribune.com/news/short-news-briefing-set-for-thurs.... Accessed 15 Oct 2022
    1. Duluth News-Tribune (2005) Another search for Lake Superior barrels: Military waste: defense department and Red Cliff Band will reopen the mystery/Red Cliff Band got grant to investigate, Apr 29, 1/2

C. Primary sources: reports

    1. Böttcher C, Knobloch T, Sternheim J, Weinberg I, Wichert U, Wöhler J (2015) Munitionsbelastung der deutschen meeresgewässer—entwicklungen und fortschritt. Ministerium für Energiewende, Landwirtschaft, Umwelt und ländliche Räume des Landes Schleswig-Holstein, Kiel
    1. Böttcher C, Knobloch T, Rühl N-P, Sternheim J, Wichert U, Wöhler J (2011) Munitionsbelastung der deutschen Meeresgewässer—Bestandsaufnahme und Empfehlungen. Technical report, Bundesamt für Seeschifffahrt und Hydrographie, Hamburg
    1. Dempsey B (2008) Review of Lake Superior barrel health consultation. https://www.health.state.mn.us/communities/environment/hazardous/docs/si.... Accessed 5 Dec 2022
    1. EMR, Inc. (2014). Draft remedial investigation report. Lake Superior barrels project, Duluth, MN. Prepared for Red Cliff Band of Lake Superior Chippewa. Minneapolis
    1. Environmental Research Laboratory—Duluth (1976) Summary of Water Analyses. Pertinent to the barrels in Lake Superior. United States Environmental Protection Agency, Duluth

D. Primary sources: justice case

    1. Supreme Court of Michigan (1971) People v. Jondreau: 384 Mich. 539, 233, N.W.2d 375

E. Secondary sources

    1. Albright R. Cleanup of chemical and explosive munitions: location, identification and environmental remediation. Oxford-Waltham: Elsevier; 2012.
    1. Arison HL., III . European disposal operations: the sea disposal of chemical weapons. Tucson: Create Space Independent Publishing Patform; 2013.
    1. Ashworth W. The late, great lakes: an environmental history. Detroit: Wayne State University Press; 1987.
    1. Ayrault S, Meybeck M, Mouchel J-M, Gaspéri J, Lestel L, Lorgeoux C, Boust D. Sedimentary archives reveal the concealed history of micropollutant contamination in the Seine River Basin. Hdb Env Chem. 2021;90:269–300. doi: 10.1007/698-2019-386. - DOI
    1. Beck AJ, Gledhill M, Schlosser C, Stamer B, Böttcher C, Sternheim J, Greinert J, Achterber EP. Spread, behavior, and ecosystem consequences of conventional munitions compounds in coastal marine waters. Front Mar Sci. 2018;5:141. doi: 10.3389/fmars.2018.00141. - DOI

LinkOut - more resources