Conservative versus surgical management of isolated O'Driscoll II coronoid fracture: A systematic review

Abstract

Purpose: The purpose of this systematic review is to summarize the current literature on conservative and surgical management of isolated O'Driscoll II coronoid fracture.

Study design: Systematic review.

Methods: We systematically searched Medline, Embase, Google Scholar, and Web of Science databases for published studies by complying with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines and using the keywords "isolated coronoid fracture," "O'Driscoll type 2 coronoid fracture," "anteromedial coronoid fracture," "anteromedial facet coronoid fracture," "posteromedial rotatory instability," and "varus posteromedial rotatory instability." Patients were divided into conservative treatment and surgical treatment groups. Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine and Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies were assessed to determine each article's quality. The primary outcomes of the present reviews were the Mayo elbow performance score (MEPS) and the disabilities of the arm, shoulder, and hand (DASH) score, and the secondary outcomes were associated with complications and reoperations. Eligible trials were independently chosen by two review authors, and a third reviewer resolved all disagreements.

Results: The search yielded 458 records, among which 446 articles were of relevance, and 12 were included. In the final review, 138 patients were evaluated-98 (71%) who received surgical treatment and 40 (29%) who received conservative treatment. The mean MEPS score and the DASH score of surgical treatment were 91 and 8, respectively; 69.8% of patients had excellent scores, and 27.0% had good scores. The mean MEPS score and the DASH score of conservative treatment were 92 and 12, respectively; 70.6% of patients had excellent scores, and 23.5% had good scores.

Conclusions: In select cases, conservative treatment can achieve good results in the treatment of isolated O'Driscoll II coronoid fracture when a stricter indication is followed. However, there is insufficient evidence to recommend the appropriate treatment for a particular fracture subtype, and there is a need for more high-quality randomized controlled trials to determine which treatment is superior.

Keywords: Conservative versus surgical; Isolated O'Driscoll II coronoid fracture; Systematic review; Varus posteromedial rotatory instability.