Qualitative Analysis of Patient Experiences Reaching Urethroplasty for Recurrent Urethral Stricture Disease

Abstract

Purpose: Despite the inferior outcomes, urethral stricture patients often undergo multiple endoscopic procedures prior to undergoing definitive urethroplasty. We sought to qualitatively evaluate the patient experience of obtaining urethroplasty to better understand the impact of this experience on quality of life.

Materials and methods: Patients treated with urethroplasty between September 2019 and July 2021 were identified and invited to participate in our study if they had undergone ≥ 2 endoscopic procedures prior to urethroplasty. Semistructured telephone interviews were conducted, coded, and analyzed using an iterative inductive-deductive approach.

Results: Of the 105 urethroplasty patients during the study period, 50 (47.6%) had undergone ≥ 2 endoscopic procedures prior (IQR 3-5), of whom 20 participated in the study. Qualitative themes related to repeat endoscopic procedures included unmet treatment expectations, dissatisfaction with catheterization and repeat procedures, and negative impacts of recurrent stricture symptoms and treatments on quality of life. External factors associated with a delay to urethroplasty included financial constraints, surgeon access, and time off work.

Conclusions: A trajectory of declining quality of life and unmet treatment expectations are the primary factors driving the decision to proceed with urethroplasty. However, external factors such as recovery costs and access to specialists play important roles in delaying surgery. These findings illustrate the need for improved community provider education and patient counseling to better inform expectations of both patients and providers with various treatment outcomes. Furthermore, these data highlight the need to improve access to specialized care for urethral stricture patients.

Keywords: mixed methods analysis; reconstructive surgical procedures; semistructured interviews; urethral stricture; urethroplasty.