Titanium versus stainless steel alloy bridge plates for distal femur fractures: Does callus form earlier with titanium?

Abstract

Introduction: Distal femur fractures account for 3-6% of all femur fractures. Internal fixation of most distal femur fractures with an anatomic lateral locking plate should permit some motion at the metaphyseal portion of the fracture when secondary bone healing is planned by the operating surgeon. While several studies have been performed evaluating union rates for distal femur fractures with stainless steel and titanium plates, the timing of callus formation between stainless steel and titanium implants used as bridge plates for distal femur fractures (AO/OTA 33-A and -C) has been investigated to a lesser extent. We hypothesize that callus will be visualized earlier with post-operative radiographs with titanium versus stainless steel bridge plates.

Methods: We retrospectively reviewed a consecutive cohort of patients over 18 years of age with acute AO/OTA 33-A and 33-C fracture patterns treated with an isolated stainless steel or titanium lateral bridge plate within 4 weeks of injury by a single fellowship-trained orthopedic trauma surgeon from 2011 to 2020 at one academic Level 1 trauma center. An independent, fellowship-trained orthopedic trauma attending surgeon reviewed anterior-posterior (AP) and lateral radiographs from every available post-operative clinic visit and graded them using the Modified Radiographic Score for Tibia (mRUST).

Results: Twenty-five subjects were included in the study with 10 with stainless steel and 15 with titanium plates. There were no significant differences in demographics between both groups, including age, sex, BMI, injury classification, open versus closed, mechanism, and laterality. Statistically significant increased mRUST scores, indicating increased callus formation, were seen on 12-week radiographs (8.4 vs. 11.9, p = 0.02) when titanium bridge plates were used. There were no statistically significant differences in mRUST scores at 6 or 24-weeks, but scores in the titanium group were higher in at every timepoint.

Discussion: In conclusion, we observed greater callus formation at 12 weeks after internal fixation of 33-A and 33-C distal femur fractures treated with titanium locked lateral distal femoral bridge plates compared to stainless steel plates. Our data suggest that titanium metallurgy may have quicker callus formation compared to stainless steel if an isolated, lateral locked bridge plate is chosen for distal femur fracture fixation.

Keywords: Callus; Distal femur; Fracture; Stainless steel; Titanium.