Comparative Effectiveness of Negative Pressure Wound Therapy with and Without Oxidized Regenerated Cellulose/Collagen/Silver-ORC Dressing

Abstract

Objective: Negative pressure wound therapy (NPWT) and oxidized regenerated cellulose (ORC)/collagen/silver-ORC (OCSO) dressings have individually demonstrated effectiveness in supporting wound healing, but few studies have examined their combined use. This retrospective data analysis compared wound outcomes following outpatient NPWT with and without OCSO dressings. Approach: A search of deidentified records from the U.S. Wound Registry resulted in 485 cases of wounds managed with NPWT with OCSO dressings. A matched cohort of patients who received NPWT without any collagen dressing (n = 485) was created using propensity scoring. For patients in the NPWT + OCSO group, OCSO was applied topically on or after the day of NPWT initiation and stopped on or before the day of NPWT termination. Results: Wounds managed with NPWT + OCSO were significantly more likely to improve and/or heal compared with wounds that received NPWT alone (p = 0.00029). The relative wound area reduction was 40% for patients receiving NPWT + OCSO, compared with 9% for patients receiving only NPWT (p = 0.0099). The median time to achieve 75-100% granulation coverage with no measurable wound depth was shorter by 8 days with NPWT + OCSO in all wound types (p = 0.00034), and by 14 days in surgical wounds (p = 0.0010), than with NPWT alone. Innovation: This is the first study examining the clinical outcomes associated with the integration of NPWT and OCSO dressings compared with the use of NPWT alone. These data support the novel practice of applying NPWT concurrently with OCSO dressings. Conclusion: This retrospective comparative analysis using real-world data demonstrated improved healing outcomes with integrated use of NPWT with OCSO dressings versus NPWT alone.

Keywords: granulation tissue; negative pressure wound therapy; retrospective; wound healing.