Further delineation of short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase deficiency in the Pacific population

Abstract

Short-chain enoyl-coA hydratase (SCEH) deficiency due to biallelic pathogenic ECHS1 variants was first reported in 2014 in association with Leigh syndrome (LS) and increased S-(2-carboxypropyl)cysteine excretion. It is potentially treatable with a valine-restricted, high-energy diet and emergency regimen. Recently, Simon et al. described four Samoan children harbouring a hypomorphic allele (c.489G > A, p.Pro163=) associated with reduced levels of normally-spliced mRNA. This synonymous variant, missed on standard genomic testing, is prevalent in the Samoan population (allele frequency 0.17). Patients with LS and one ECHS1 variant were identified in NZ and Australian genomic and clinical databases. ECHS1 sequence data were interrogated for the c.489G > A variant and clinical data were reviewed. Thirteen patients from 10 families were identified; all had Pacific ancestry including Samoan, Māori, Cook Island Māori, and Tokelauan. All developed bilateral globus pallidi lesions, excluding one pre-symptomatic infant. Symptom onset was in early childhood, and was triggered by illness or starvation in 9/13. Four of 13 had exercise-induced dyskinesia, 9/13 optic atrophy and 6/13 nystagmus. Urine S-(2-carboxypropyl)cysteine-carnitine and other SCEH-related metabolites were normal or mildly increased. Functional studies demonstrated skipping of exon four and markedly reduced ECHS1 protein. These data provide further support for the pathogenicity of this ECHS1 variant which is also prevalent in Māori, Cook Island Māori, and Tongan populations (allele frequency 0.14-0.24). It highlights the need to search for a second variant in apparent heterozygotes with an appropriate phenotype, and has implications for genetic counselling in family members who are heterozygous for the more severe ECHS1 alleles. SYNOPSIS: Short-chain enoyl-CoA hydratase deficiency is a frequent cause of Leigh-like disease in Māori and wider-Pacific populations, due to the high carrier frequency of a hypomorphic ECHS1 variant c.489G > A, p.[Pro163=, Phe139Valfs*65] that may be overlooked by standard genomic testing.

Keywords: ECHS1; Hypomorphic variant; Pacific; Populations; Short chain enoylcoA hydratase deficiency.