A Survey of Current Approaches to Inguinal Hernia Repair by Pediatric General Surgeons in the United States

Abstract

Introduction: Inguinal hernia repair (IHR) is a common pediatric operation performed via open or laparoscopic approaches. The objective of this survey study was to assess current approaches to IHR in a national sample of pediatric general surgeons.

Methods: A REDCap survey was distributed to all pediatric general surgeons at 21 US institutions in 2023. Descriptive statistics were used to analyze responses.

Results: The response rate was 70.0% (145/207) with median fellowship graduation year of 2011. Respondents reported they were primarily taught either an open (73.1%) or laparoscopic (6.9%) technique in fellowship, while 18.6% reported being taught both techniques equally. Overall, 60.7% of respondents reported currently performing both laparoscopic and open IHR, while 27.6% reported performing only open IHR and 11.7% reported performing only laparoscopic IHR. During unilateral open IHR, 75.8% of respondents check for and repair a contralateral inguinal hernia, most commonly by placing a laparoscope via the hernia sac (76.3%). Selective mesh use in adolescents was similar between laparoscopic and open repair approaches. For recurrent hernias, 37.2% of respondents indicated performing the approach that was not performed previously, while 38.6% and 22.8% indicated they routinely perform a laparoscopic or open approach, respectively, regardless of initial repair approach.

Conclusion: Over two thirds of surgeons reported incorporating laparoscopic IHR into their practice despite nearly three-quarters of respondents indicating they were primarily taught an open approach in training. Training in laparoscopic IHR has been increasing over time, and respondents reported a wide variety of laparoscopic and open repair techniques.

Level of evidence: IV.

Keywords: Inguinal hernia repair; Laparoscopy; Pediatric inguinal hernia; Pediatric surgery.