Femoral neck fracture: sliding screw plate versus sliding nail plate--a randomized trial

Abstract

In a randomized trial 49 patients with fracture of the neck of the femur and an age of less than 70 years or a high level of physical activity were allocated to treatment with a sliding screw plate or a sliding nail plate fixation. The patients were followed for 2-5 years. At follow-up the union rate was found to be 86.2 per cent of the fractures in the screw plate group and 73.7 per cent in the nail plate group (P less than 0.3). Necrosis of the femoral head was encountered in respectively 10 and 21 per cent. Hip replacement was necessary in respectively 23.3 and 31.6 per cent. The nail slid out of the femoral head, resulting in recurrence of the fracture's displacement in three fractures with a sliding nail plate, and in none with a sliding screw plate (P = 0.053). Secondary loss of the femoral neck's angle was more frequently seen in the sliding nail plate group (P less than 0.01). In conclusion, the sliding screw plate gives better fixation of fractures of the neck of the femur and was followed by a lower frequency of reoperation than after an unthreaded device.