Implementation of maternal and perinatal death surveillance and response and related death review interventions in humanitarian settings: A scoping review

Abstract

Background: The global population impacted by humanitarian crises continues to break records each year, leaving strained and fractured health systems reliant upon humanitarian assistance in more than 60 countries. Yet little is known about implementation of maternal and perinatal death surveillance and response (MPDSR) within crisis-affected contexts. This scoping review aimed to synthesise evidence on the implementation of MPDSR and related death review interventions in humanitarian settings.

Methods: We searched for peer-reviewed and grey literature in English and French published in 2016-22 that reported on MPDSR and related death review interventions within humanitarian settings. We screened and reviewed 1405 records, among which we identified 25 peer-reviewed articles and 11 reports. We then used content and thematic analysis to understand the adoption, appropriateness, fidelity, penetration, and sustainability of these interventions.

Results: Across the 36 records, 33 unique programmes reported on 37 interventions within humanitarian contexts in 27 countries, representing 69% of the countries with a 2023 United Nations humanitarian appeal. Most identified programmes focussed on maternal death interventions; were in the pilot or early-mid implementation phases (1-5 years); and had limited integration within health systems. While we identified substantive documentation of MPDSR and related death review interventions, extensive gaps in evidence remain pertaining to the adoption, fidelity, penetration, and sustainability of these interventions. Across humanitarian contexts, implementation was influenced by severe resource limitations, variable leadership, pervasive blame culture, and mistrust within communities.

Conclusions: Emergent MPDSR implementation dynamics show a complex interplay between humanitarian actors, communities, and health systems, worthy of in-depth investigation. Future mixed methods research evaluating the gamut of identified MPDSR programmes in humanitarian contexts will greatly bolster the evidence base. Investment in comparative health systems research to understand how best to adapt MPDSR and related death review interventions to humanitarian contexts is a crucial next step.

Figure 1

MPDSR and related death review interventions.

Figure 2

Search strategy flow diagram.

Figure 3

Key study outcome measures and constructs. DRC – Democratic Republic of Congo, EMPHNET – Eastern Mediterranean Public Health Network, GHD – Global Health and Development, JSANDS – Jordan stillbirth and neonatal death surveillance, MDSR – maternal death surveillance and response, MESI – integrated monitoring, evaluation, and surveillance system, MNDSR – maternal and neonatal death surveillance and response, MPMSR – maternal and perinatal mortality surveillance and response MSP – Ministere de la Sante Publique, N/R – not reported, PNIPH – Palestinian National Institute of Public Health, RDC – République Démocratique du Congo, UNFPA – United Nations Population Fund.