Use of influenza A virus vaccines in seronegative children: live cold-adapted versus inactivated whole virus

Abstract

We report the safety and antigenicity of influenza A vaccines in seronegative children one to seven years of age. A natural H1N1 challenge that occurred shortly after completion of the vaccination program permitted an evaluation of efficacy. Twenty-eight subjects were inoculated with live cold-adapted (ca) influenza A/Washington/897/80 (H3N2), 29 with ca influenza A/California/10/78 (H1N1), 24 with inactivated whole-virus influenza A/Bangkok/79 (H3N2), and 30 with a placebo. The ca vaccines were well tolerated, whereas the inactivated vaccine caused adverse reactions in about one-third of the children. Fifty-seven percent of the ca H1N1 recipients showed serological responses, contrasted with 84% and 100% of subjects receiving the ca or inactivated H3N2 vaccines, respectively. None of the 16 children with induced H1N1 antibody developed clinically apparent influenza-like illness, compared with eleven of the 51 initially seronegative children who did not receive the ca H1N1 vaccine and with four of the 12 who failed to respond. Results of the efficacy field trial suggest protection against infection and symptomatic illness in children inoculated with ca H1N1, despite its failure to stimulate high levels of hemagglutinin-inhibiting antibody.