A curious case of a negative control line on a dengue duo assay due to interference - A case report

Abstract

An elderly patient who presented with 1 week of fever and respiratory symptoms was tested for dengue infection with an Abbott Bioline™ Dengue Duo immunochromatographic assay. Unexpectedly, the control line of the dengue non-structural protein 1 (NS1) component was absent, necessitating result invalidation. It remained absent when the test was repeated on the SD Biosensor Standard™ Q Dengue Duo, but present on the Wells Bio careUS^TM Dengue Combo and Asan Easy Test® Dengue DUO assays, suggesting potential interference. Dilution, polyethylene glycol (PEG) precipitation and centrifugation with a 100 kDa filter were performed to reduce/remove the potential interferent. Sera from other patients that showed a control line, and a test line that was either positive or negative for NS1, were used as controls. Upon dilution with negative control serum, a faint control line emerged. PEG precipitation resulted in disappearance of control and test lines in the positive control. Filtration led to emergence of the control line for the patient's serum but caused the test line for the positive control serum to disappear. Overall, investigations suggested the presence of a high molecular weight (>100 kDa) substance which interferes with chicken IgY-anti-chicken IgY binding at the control line of affected assays. Our results highlight two important points: firstly, some commonly used laboratory procedures (e.g. PEG or filtration) may inadvertently remove the target biomarker (e.g. multimeric NS1) and should be interpreted with appropriate controls. Secondly, alternative kits that use a different antigen-antibody combination for the control line can be considered when similar patients are encountered in future.

Keywords: Dengue; case report; immunochromatography; interference; point-of-care testing.