Experiences and preferences of women with CAH and parents about disclosure of childhood surgery

Abstract

Introduction: Complete disclosure of childhood genital surgery to patients with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) is a critical part of CAH care. There are no guidelines or uniform recommendations on the timing and content of surgical disclosure discussions.

Objective: Our objective was to describe the experiences and preferences of females with CAH and parents of females with CAH who underwent childhood genital surgery regarding surgical disclosure.

Methods: We conducted an anonymous cross-sectional online survey of females with CAH (46XX, ≥16 years [y] old) and parents of females with CAH who underwent genital surgery before age 4y in North America. Participants reported experiences, preferences, and advice about initial ("first time you were told") and complete disclosure ("told all details"). Non-parametric statistics and qualitative analysis were used.

Results: Participants included 59 females with CAH (median age: 37y, 92% White, 93% non-Hispanic) and 41 parents (median: 36y, 85% White, 93% non-Hispanic, daughter median: 26y). The 76% of females who received complete disclosure were younger (median age: 33y) and underwent surgery more recently (median decade: 1980s) than the 14% who received only initial disclosure (median: 47y, 1970s) and the 10% who did not receive any disclosure (median: 60y, 1960s, p = 0.0003, Summary Figure). Females reported median ages of initial and complete disclosure as 7-10y and 11-13y, respectively. Disclosure was preferred by 98% of females with initial disclosure by age 14y and complete disclosure by 18y. Parents reported similar findings. Most disclosures were by mothers (initial: 82%, complete: 64%). Doctors were more involved in complete vs. initial disclosures (complete: 47%, initial: 13%, p < 0.001). Qualitative analysis of advice about surgical disclosure revealed 8 themes.

Conclusions: Disclosure of childhood genital surgery to women with CAH has increased over time. Although timing of disclosure varied, women preferred disclosure, and that it be initiated before age 14y and completed by age 18y.

Keywords: Adrenal hyperplasia; Congenital; Differences of sex development; Patient reported outcome measures.