Orangutans and chimpanzees produce morphologically varied laugh facesin response to the age and sex of their social partners

Abstract

Laugh faces of humans play a key role in everyday social interactions as a pervasive tool of communication across contexts. Humans often vary the degree of mouth opening and teeth exposure when producing these facial expressions, which may depend on who their social partner is (e.g., their gender and age as well as their social relationship), serving this way different functions. Although it was found that laugh faces show evolutionary continuity across humans and non-human great apes according to the Principle of Maximum Parsimony, little is known about the function of laugh face variations from an evolutionary perspective. Hence, the present work examined the morphology of laugh faces in orangutan and chimpanzee dyadic play to test if they are modified with dependence on the playmate's characteristics (sex, age and social relationship). In total, we analysed over 600 facial expressions of 14 orangutans and 17 chimpanzees by coding the specific muscle activations (Action Units, i.e. AUs) contributing to these expressions, using OrangFACS and ChimpFACS, respectively. Our results suggest that age difference and, to a lesser extent, playmate sex influence laugh face morphology in both taxa, but in opposite ways. While the orangutans of our study seem to expose their upper teeth (with AU10) and to pull the mouth corners (with AU12) more towards weaker partners (younger and female), possibly to communicate non-hostility, the chimpanzees showed both upper and lower teeth exposure (with AU10 and AU16) more often when interacting with the stronger partners (older individuals), possibly to communicate submissiveness. These findings suggest that the ability of humans to modify laugh faces with dependence on social partner characteristics has most likely evolved from pre-existing traits, going back at least to the last common ancestor of today's great apes, including humans.

Keywords: Chimpanzees; Laugh faces; Open-mouth faces; Orangutans; Smile; Social play.

Fig. 1

Examples of laugh faces in orangutans (left) and chimpanzees (right). First row: lip parting (AU25), jaw dropping (AU26) and lower lip depressor (AU16); second row: lip parting (AU25), mouth stretch (AU27), upper lip raiser (AU10) and lower lip depressor (AU16). For a scheme of the AUs typically involved in a laugh face see Davila-Ross and colleagues, and for more details about AUs in these taxa, see the OrangFACS and ChimpFACS manuals^,.