Comparison of four beta-blockers as assessed by 24-hour ECG recording

Abstract

beta-Blockers are used as if they were equivalent. With ECG recordings in 42 patients we investigated the effect on sinus heart rate of four beta-blockers given at three successive daily doses. Heart rate was dose-dependently decreased by all drugs except acebutolol, the effect of which decreased at a higher dosage. The maximal effects of metoprolol, nadolol, and propranolol were similar but the drugs differed in potency (dosage producing 50% of maximal effect, calculated from the dose-effect relationships; nadolol, 0.3 mg/day; metoprolol, 120 mg/day; propranolol, 47 mg/day). Similar relationships were found with drug plasma concentrations (concentration producing 50% of maximal effect: nadolol, 3.5 ng/ml; metoprolol, 21 ng/ml; propranolol, 36 ng/ml) and with supine or upright heart rates and blood pressures. However, the drugs were not equivalent: In addition to its greater potency, nadolol differed from propranolol and metoprolol in the slope of its dose-response curve. We conclude that beta-blockers can be compared by ECG recordings and that nadolol is different from the other beta-blockers without intrinsic sympathomimetic activity.