Prominence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis biomarkers among sputum culture-negative clinic attendees, independent of Ultra status

Abstract

Background: Highly-sensitive molecular tests like GeneXpert MTB/RIF Ultra improve detection of paucibacillary pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) but occasionally detect Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) DNA in sputum from culture-negative individuals, with unclear significance. We hypothesized that Ultra may be detecting culture-negative TB, and manifest in a higher prevalence of TB biomarkers compared to Ultra-negative/culture-negative ('sputum-negative') individuals.

Methods: From 1200 symptomatic African adults undergoing evaluation for TB, we identified 66 with discordant results (Ultra-positive, culture-negative), and matched 52 sputum-negative (Ultra-negative, culture-negative) and 30 sputum-positive (Ultra-positive, culture-positive) participants. Over 12 months, participants were assessed for Mtb biomarkers (Mtb growth in augmented or follow-up sputum cultures, Mtb mRNA in baseline sputum, and symptomatic Ultra-positive after baseline) and TB-associated host transcriptional signatures.

Results: At baseline, TB-associated biomarker(s) were detected in 51.5 % of sputum-discordant versus 59.6 % of sputum-negative participants (p = 0.46), with at least one Mtb biomarker in 16.7 % versus 26.9 % respectively (p = 0.26). Longitudinally, 26.5 % of untreated sputum-discordant versus 41.7 % of untreated sputum-negative participants had Mtb biomarkers (p = 0.17) despite most reporting symptom improvement. Notably, 30 % of untreated sputum-negative participants converted to Ultra-positive at month 2. One sputum-discordant and one sputum-negative participant developed culture-confirmed TB at follow-up.

Conclusion: TB bacterial and host biomarkers were prevalent and no different between sputum-discordant and sputum-negative participants, raising concern for a considerable population of undiagnosed culture-negative TB. These findings parallel new evidence of Mtb aerosolization from sputum-negative individuals and highlight a need for more comprehensive diagnostics that detect sputum culture-negative TB with respect to infectiousness, pathology, and risk of progression.

Keywords: Culture-negative; Diagnosis; Paucibacillary; Tuberculosis; Ultra.