How to approach a patient hospitalized for pneumonia who is not responding to treatment?

Abstract

Pneumonia is a frequent cause of intensive care unit (ICU) admission and is the most common infection in ICU patients across all geographic regions. It takes 48-72h for most patients to respond to appropriate antibiotic therapy. Non-response is typically defined as the persistence/worsening of clinical signs-such as fever, respiratory distress, impaired oxygenation and/or radiographic abnormalities-with rates ranging 20-30%. Several factors can contribute to non-response. Host factors, including immunosuppression, chronic lung disease, or ongoing aspiration, may impair resolution. Additionally, incorrect antibiotic dosing, atypical or resistant pathogens (such as multidrug-resistant bacteria, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, or fungal infections) may be responsible, requiring alternative antimicrobial strategies. A septic complication related to pneumonia (e.g., empyema) or not (e.g., acalculous cholecystitis) may need to be excluded. Finally, non-infectious conditions (e.g., pulmonary embolism, malignancy, secondary ARDS or vasculitis) that can mimic or potentiate pneumonia must be considered. Although non-responding pneumonia is frequent, its management lacks strong evidence, and its approach is based mostly on the art of medicine and clinical judgement. Clinicians should continuously reassess the medical history and physical exam, review microbiological data, and consider imaging such as chest CT. Bronchoscopy or repeat sputum sampling may aid in identifying alternative pathogens or non-infectious causes. The management of a non-responding pneumonia depends on the findings of a structured reassessment. Herein, we provide guidance on how to identify and manage non-responding pneumonia. Ultimately, addressing pneumonia that does not respond to antibiotics is crucial for preventing complications, optimizing antimicrobial stewardship, and improving patient outcomes.

Keywords: Community-acquired pneumonia; Hospital-acquired pneumonia; Management; Nonresponding pneumonia; Pneumonia; Ventilator-associated pneumonia.

Fig. 1

How and when to define a non-responding pneumonia; a patient is considered a non-responder after at least 48-72h of appropriate antibiotic therapy; the identification of non-response results from an integrated re-evaluation of clinical signs and symptoms, lab results namely biomarkers, microbiologic results and no improvement or further progression of imaging infiltrates (see manuscript)

Fig. 2

Non-responding pneumonia presenting the differential diagnosis and the proposed diagnostic work-up